Difference between tadabbur and tafsir

un natural way ko agar follow karein ge aap toh sirf nakami hogi. is mein koi kuch milne wala nahi aap ko. Maulana, agla sawal hai Mr Sultan Kashmiri ka. unhon ne likha hai: "Maulana sahib, tadabbur aur tafsir baraye mein kya farq hai? is ke baray mein batayein." bhai, tadabbur ke maani toh contemplation, sochna. bohat achi cheez cheez hai. aap sochein, aap toh dono alag alag cheezein hain. yani Quran ko parhne ka ek matlab yeh hai ke aap is ko jo alfaaz hain, us ke baghair samjhe hue, us ki tilawat karein. toh woh kaha tadabbur ke baghair Quran ko parhna hai. ek yeh hai ke Quran ko aap parhein toh sochein. Arabic jante hain toh Arabic class samjhein, nahi toh translation parhein.

toh parh kar sochein ke kya matlab hai is ka. jaise kal mein ek sahib se baat kar raha tha ke "Alhamdulillah Rabbil Alameen" yeh pehli ayat hai Quran Majeed ki. toh maine kaha "Alhamdulillah" bas sochte sochte maloom hua ke "Alhamdulillah Rabb" jo hai, woh result hai, woh nateeja hai, asal nahi hai. asal jo hai, marifat. pehle marifat aati hai, phir "Alhamdulillah" niklta hai munh se. yeh hai sochna. aap batayein, kaise aap kahein ke "Alhamdulillah" jab tak aap is se pehle aap ke mind mein ek ek inqilab na aa chuka ho, ek intellectual revolution ke aap ne socha, aap ne Allah ko daryaft kiya, Allah ki glory ko jana, aap ne Allah ki boundaries ko jana, aap ne Allah ki blessings ko jana, aap ne yeh sab baatein aap ne jani, phir aap kahan parhein ge "Alhamdulillah Rabbil Alameen"?

toh "Alhamdulillah" se pehle marifat darkar hai. marifat nahi toh sacha "Alhamdulillah" bhi nahi. yeh hai sochna. baqi jo tafsir baraye hai, woh toh aise hai ke yani aap na Arabic jaanein, na Arabic ko follow karein, na Quran ke jo shan e nazool hai, us ko follow karein. bas yun hi ult pult kuch kahein. jaise kuch log kehte hain ke imaan ka matlab aman hai, aman ka nizam qaim karo, salat ka matlab hai social nizam, social nizam qaim k ro. aisi ulti pulti baatein hain. is ka koi talluq na siwaq se hota, na lughat se hota, na doosri jo mufassireen hain un se hota, na shan e nazool se hota.

toh tafsir baraye ka matlab hai ke bas apni rai yun hi dena, aur jabke yani baghair gehrai se baat ko samjhe hue, toh tafsir baraye toh bilashuba galat baat hai. woh toh galat hai, bilkul is mein koi shaq nahi hai. lekin sochna jo hai, bohat bari cheez hai. agar tadabbur nahi karein ge aap toh Quran ki gehri baaton ko aap pakar nahi paein ge. toh tadabbur bohat hi zaroori hai, aur tafsir baraye jo hai, woh apni rai par chalana hai. kuch bhi baatein karna hai apne apni rai ke mutabiq. yani yeh yeh nahi sochna ke Quran ke alfaaz se woh baat nikalti hai ke nahi nikalti hai.

Maulana, agla sawal hai Mr Mukarram Hussain Qasmi sahib ka Delhi se. unhon ne likha hai: "jo Musalman Hindu community se nafrat karte hain, un ke baray mein aap kya kahein ge?" woh ek haram feal karte hain.