Why is breaking idols wrong when Prophet did it?
“Maulana, you said in your March 8 speech that breaking idols by Taliban or ISIS is wrong. But from the Seerah, it is known that after the conquest of Mecca, the Prophet sent companions to break the idols of Arabia, e.g., Khalid bin Walid to break the idol of Uzza, Amr bin al-As to Suwa, Abu Sufyan and Mughira to break Lat, etc. Why is it wrong when the Prophet did it?”Asked by محمد امیر صدیقی, نوئیڈا
He answers at 43:38 in Problem and Shukr · 2 min 19 sec
43:38Maulana, yeh sawal jo aaya hai woh Noida se hai Muhammad Ameer Siddiqui sahab ka, aur unhone likha hai ke Maulana, aap ne 8 March ki taqreer mein yeh kaha tha ke butkhana jo aaj kal Taliban ya ISIS wale tod rahe hain, woh galat hai. magar seerat se yeh maloom hota hai ke fateh e Makkah ke baad Rasool Allah ne apne kuch sahaba ko Arab ke butkhanon ko todne ke liye bheja tha, maslan Khalid bin Waleed ko Uzza ka but todne ke liye bheja, Amr bin Al-Aas ko Suwa ke liye, Abu Sufyan aur Mughira ko, Mughira bin Shuba ko Laat ke liye waghera. in tamam logon ne Arabon ke butkhanon ko destroy kar diya.
44:31is ki wazahat farmayein. Yeh waqiat Seerat un Nabi, Shibli Nomani, volume 1, page 339 mein maujood hain. Dekhiye, is se koi talluq nahi hai. historical monument ka mamla alag hai, woh mamla alag hai. Woh aqeedah ka mamla hai jis ko toda hai unhone. Wahan na aqeedah ka mamla tha, na shirk ka mamla tha, wahan k ch bhi nahi tha. Woh to sirf ek khandar tha, bas. Aur wahan jo tha, woh yaani shirk ko khatam karna Allah ka Rasool ka nishana tha. to woh living shirk ke adde the, woh. Aur woh kya? Woh to kuch bhi nahi, woh to khandar hai. Ya aap log jo hain, galat tareekhein padhte hain, galat tareekhein padh kar ke yeh sab zeh
45:15n banta hai. Aap ko main kahunga ke meri kitab padhiye, "Ghaur al-Inqilab" aur woh seerat par meri kai kitabein hain, us ko padhiye. yeh galat tareekhein padh padh ke aap ko zehn yeh banaya. khulasa yeh hai ke Arab mein jo butkhane the, woh living adde the, zinda adde the shirk ke. Aur Iraq mein jis ko toda gaya hai, woh to taqreeban teen hazar saal pehle ka khandar tha, is ka koi woh shirk se koi talluq nahi tha. ab to woh siyahon ki cheez thi, woh siyahon ki cheez thi. Ji
45:57Maulana, agla sawal lene se pehle ek comment padhna chahenge jo Maulana Iqbal Umri ne bheja hai Chennai se, aur unhone likha hai ke Maulana, aaj hi pata chala ke sabr ka sabr ka matlab hai man made problem ko manage karne ka formula.