Why scholars misunderstand Quran and Hadith
“If a doctor talks to another doctor about medical matters, he understands immediately. You are a scholar and speak about Quran and Hadith, so why don't our other scholars understand your points?”Asked by مہتاب, دھامپور
He answers at 46:17 in Revival of Muslims · 3 min 40 sec
46:17maulana, yeh sawal dhampur se bheja hai mehtab sahib ne aur unhon ne likha hai ke maulana sahib, agar koi doctor kisi doosre doctor se medical line ki baat kare to woh doctor is baat ko foran samajh lega. mera sawal yeh hai ke aap bhi ek aalim hain, Quran aur Hadees ke hawale se baat karte hain, phir hamare in ulama ko aap ki baat kyun samajh mein nahi aati? bhai, aaj ki baat, aaj ka main jo bola hoon to isi par bola hoon ke cloud hai. yaani ek woh un ke aur aur asal baat ke beech mein ek ek cloud aa gaya hai, is ki wajah se samajh mein nahi aata.
47:15is ki maine misaal di, kai misaalें. to dekhen, hamare madaris ki ek ek ek ek baat yeh hai ke har madrase ko kisi baray aalim ne banaya hai. sirf ek madrassa is mein istisna hai, woh Jamia Darussalam. to madaris mein kya hai ke woh jo bani hai, unhi ko sab kuch samajh aata hai, sab kuch.
47:53to madaris ke baray mein mera tajruba yeh hai ke madrase ke parhe hue logon ke aur asal deen ke beech mein woh aalim haail hai. ke hamare Hazrat Issaquiani, maine kai baar tajruba kiya hai ke koi baat aisa mein kahoon jo Quran o Hadees ke hawale se kahoon to woh kya keh den ge? bhai, hamare Hazrat Issaquiani, hamare Hazrat, kya aap se aap kya aap se kam jante the hamare Hazrat? yeh un ka afsar hota hai, yeh un ka afsar hota hai.
48:34maine bar bar yeh tajruba kiya hai ke madrase ke log jo hain, woh apna, un ke jo apne akabir kehte hain, un ko woh un ke jo akabir ke afsar bhi jeete hain, bade the. to jab main un se baat karta hoon aur quran o hadith sunata hoon to kya keh dete hain? kya quran o hadith un ko nahin maloom tha? hamare aakabir le jate the quran o hadith ko, aap hi jante hain. to yeh hai un ki conditioning. is conditioning ko todna, yani aap jante hain ke bahut se madarse ke padhe hue bhi hamare saathi hain, un ki conditioning tooti hai.
49:22to conditioning ko tootne ki shakal yeh hai ke aap hamari kitabein parhwaien, hamari kitabein parhwaen. mujhe bahut se, yani madaris ke faraghin mein bahut se log hain jo hamare khilaf the. phir jab un ki kitabein parhwai gayin to unhon ne maan liya ke bhai yeh to baat theek hai. to mere khayal se adab ko padhana bahut zaroori hai. isi se conditioning toote gi, is ke baad un ka ikhtilaf khatm ho jayega. maulana, agla sawal dilli se aaya hai maulana farhad umri ka aur unhon ne likha hai it seems that a lot of fighters of isis are converted muslims.