Can wrong actions be justified by their plus points?
“You said that bloodshed and suicide bombing in the name of jihad is wrong, but its plus point is that it creates news which makes people study the Quran. My question is: can these wrong actions be done considering their plus point? Certainly not, so that means we will commit haram?”Asked by Maulana Abdul Wahab, Delhi
maulana abdul wahab ne dilli se sawal kiya hai unhon ne likha hai aap ne farmaya ke jihad ke naam par khoon kharaba karna ya suicide bombing karna galat hai lekin is ka plus point yeh hai ke is se news create hoti hai jis ki wajah se log quran ki study karte hain mera sawal yeh hai ke kya in galat kamon ke plus point ko dekhte hue unhein anjam diya ja sakta hai harghiz nahi to yani haram ko anjam denge aap dekhen main ne jo baat kahi koi nai baat nahi hai yeh quran mein maujood hai quran mein hai wa rafa'na laka zikrak jab madina makke mein jo log order par suppress the rasool Allah ke liye ulti seedhi baatein karne lage galat galat baatein maslan yeh ke unka Allah majnoon a a a paighambar tum to hum ko mad dikhaye parhte ho tarah tarah ki baatein to is par quran mein aya ke tum is par yani is mein ek plus point hai woh woh tumhari publicity kar rahe hain yani woh tum ko jo badnam kar rahe hain badnam apne hisab se badnam kar rahe hain woh tumhari publicity ban rahi hai woh logon logon ke andar curiosity paida ho rahi hai ke bhai kon hai bhai kya hai yeh is ka matlab nahi ke koi suicide bombing kare woh to bilashuba haram hai is mein koi suicide bombing ke haram hone mein koi shaq hi nahi jo log is ko jaiz bataye woh yani pagal se zyada zyada koi aur makhlooq honge woh suicide bombing haram ho suicide bombing islam mein jo halaal bataye woh bilashuba islam ka a b c d bhi nahi janta
to woh jo kar rahe hain woh to un ka fail hai aur bilashuba woh haram fail kar rahe hain lekin yeh dunya Allah taala is liye bani hai ke aap ko har cheez mein ek plus point mil jaye har cheez mein ek lesson mil jaye woh main ne kaha main harghiz harghiz un ko yani ke mera matlab nahi ke woh justified hai un ka un ka fail woh to bilashuba haram hai maulana sharik hussain ne dilli se sawal kiya hai unhon ne likha hai hadith mein hai ke yeh dunya momin ke liye qaid khana hai sawal yeh hai ke ek momin is dunya ko apne liye qaid khana tasawwur kare ya jannat dekhen qaid khane ke mani hain ad-dunya sil al-momin woh psychological prison ke mani mein hai material prison ke mani mein nahi hai
Machine transcription. These are his recorded words, written down by software from the Urdu he speaks — so a line may carry a misheard word. Every timestamp above opens the video at that second: one tap and you can hear him say it. Quote it as speech, and link to the moment.