Why less criticism of Deobandi writers

maulana iqbal umri ne tamil nadu se sawal likha hai. unhon ne poocha hai ke aik nadvi aalim ne sawal kiya ke kiya wajah hai ke al risalah mein nadvi writers ki fikr par tanqeed ki gayi hai, magar al risalah mein deobandi writers ki kitabon par bohat kam tanqeed pai jati hai? please is sawal ko wazeh farmayen. mein to tanqeed kabhi nahi karta, yeh galat khayal mere bare mein hai ke mein tanqeed karta hoon. mein har giz naqad nahi hoon. tanqeed dekhen, aik negative word hai, negative word hai. mera maqsad tanqeed karna nahi hai. mein intehai had tak positive aadmi hoon.

mere mere andar aik inshallah aik aik aik chota sa particle bhi negativity ka nahi hai. negativity ka koi negative particle se meri meri personality bilkul khali hai. to mein aik positive aadmi hoon. tanqeed karna mera maqsad nahi hai. baqi jo kuch mein kehta hoon, us ko aap wahin mein daleel bhi deta hoon, wahin mein jahan kehta hoon. mein baaniyah andaaz mein koi baat nahi kehta ke falan bara acha hai, falan bohat kharab hai. yeh baaniyah andaaz hai. yeh mein ne kabhi nahi karta aisa.

kahin kisi kitab mein aap nahi kar sakte ke mein is yeh zuban bolta hoon, yaani hajj ki zuban aur qaziya khwani ki zuban. yeh meri zuban nahi hai. log kiya kehte hain? kisi ka qaziya parh rahe hain, kisi ka hajj kar rahe hain. yeh meri zuban hi nahi hai. jahan mein koi baat kehta hoon, wahin wahin ke wahin daleel daleel deta hoon. to meri baat ko aap is tarah mat dekhiye, is khane mein bant kar ke, balkeh sirf yeh dekhiye ke wahan jo baat mein ne kahi hai, to daleel ke sath kahin be daleel kahiye, bas. aur koi dosra mi'yar wahan par mat apply kijiye aap. warna mere sath aap justice nahi karein ge, mere sath insaaf nahi karein ge.

maulana, yeh sawal kiya hai mr. ashique lone sahib ne jammu kashmir se. unhon ne likha hai ke Allah taala sees in quran chapter 49 verse number 13: "o mankind! we have created you from one male and one female, and set you in tribes and nations, so that you know one another. but there is still one hadith which confuses me, which is: my ummah will be divided into 73 sects.

maulana, what does this sect mean?" dekhen, quran mein jo hai, woh physical sense mein hai, woh ideological sense mein nahi hai. jo ayat quran ki likhi hai aap ne: "jis jins se mard banaye, usi jins aurat bhi banai." yeh matlab is ka, yaani physical identity, woh ideal sense mein nahi hai, woh ideological sense mein nahi hai. agar agar sab ka fikr aik hi dhal dhal diya jaye to imtehan khatm ho jaye ga. imtehan kahan hoga? insaan ko jo freedom of choice hai, woh wohi to asal hai. to woh jo hai, quran mein jo ayat hai, us ko sirf physical identity ke mani mein lijiye aap

yani jo jis jins se mard ko banaya, usi jins se aurat ko banaya. aur jahan tak hadith ka muamla hai, woh to ek alag cheez hai. kyunke duniya mein dekhiye, imtehan hai sab ka. yeh nahi ke musalman exempted hain imtehan se. yeh mat samjhiye ke musalman exempted hain test se. sab ka test hai to musalmanon ke upar test bhi hai. jis tarah doosre log bhagte hain, use musalman bhi bhagega. yeh matlab hai is ka. log samajhte hain ke musalman jo exempted hain, ummat-e-marhooma hai ya bilkul baseless hai yeh aqeedah.

to har ek ke bhagne ke maidan alag alag hote hain. koi kisi tarah bhagta hai, koi kis tarah bhagta hai. to doosron ke bhagne ki field secular hoti hai. wo secular maidan mein utra hai ke aqeedah banate hain. musalmanon ki field jo hai, woh mazhabi hai. mazhabi field mein alag alag aqeeday banate hain. to musalmanon ka bhi apni azadi ko mehsoos karega. musalman is se sab firqe banenge aur doosron ka bhi azadi ko mehsoos karenge. is se woh sab un ke haan mukhtalif qism ki baatein paida hongi. to basic baat yeh samajh lijiye ke musalman ne hargiz hargiz test se exempted nahi hai.

sab ka imtehan ho raha hai aur yeh sari baatein isi liye hain ke aadmi apne azadi ko misuse karta hai. maulana, yeh sawal kiya hai qazi mahmood ahmed qasmi sahib ne jammu kashmir se. unhone likha hai ke sirat-e-mustaqeem kya hai, is ke baray mein batayen.