Are both sides in early battles in Paradise?
“People say that in the battles of Jamal and Siffin, those who were killed on both sides are all in Paradise. Is this belief correct?”Asked by مسٹر راج ملک, دلی
He answers at 59:28 in Surah Al-'Asr I · 3 min 33 sec
59:28Maulana, agla sawal Mr Raj Malik ne kiya hai Dilli se aur unhone likha hai ke Maulana, log kehte hain ke Jang-e-Jamal aur Jang-e-Siffin mein dono taraf se jo log mare gaye woh dono jannati hain. kya yeh nazariya sahi hai? dekhen, main ek baat usooli arz karta hoon ke hadith mein aata hai innama al-a'malu bi al-niyyat amal ka daromadar niyat par hai. yani zahiri taur par aadmi kya karta hai woh faisle ki cheez nahi hai. uska intention kya hai woh faisle ki cheez hai. intention innama al-a'malu bi al-niyyat
1:00:24yani action depends upon intention to intention jo hai woh to Allah ko pata hai. Woh to insan ko pata nahi. mujhe ek waqia yaad aata hai. Ek sahab the, abool barkaat, un ka intiqal ho chuka hai. To Maulana Hussain Bandani ko bohat mante the. To ek martaba gaya un ke haan. woh Tanda mein rehte the. Woh Darul Uloom Deoband mein shakh al hadees bhi the. Watan tha Tanda.
1:01:01ek martaba un se milne gaye. To unhon ne bataya ke Maulana Bandani jo the bistar par leTe hue the. Aur jaisa ke aap jante hain ke Maulana Bandani Congressi zehan ke the. Muslim League ke sakht khilaf the. Muslim League ke sakht khilaf the. Janab sahab ke sakht khilaf the. woh Congressi zehan ke aadmi the. To Abool Barkaat sahab ne bataya mujhe ke is waqt jab ke woh leTe hue the aur yeh baithe hue the neeche farsh par ek aadmi aaya. is aadmi ne Maulana Bandani se ek sawal kiya
1:01:42ke Hazrat, janaza ka anjam acha hoga ya bura hoga aakhirat mein? Direct taur par. Janaza ka anjam acha hoga ya bura? to unhon ne bataya ke Maulana Bandani ne ek lamha socha. soch kar bohat hi yani specific lafzon mein ek baat kahi. Unhon ne kaha ke is ki niyat achi thi to is ka anjam bhi acha hoga. is ki niyat buri thi to is ka anjam bhi bura hoga.
1:02:20bohat bohat right statement hai yeh. Bohat sahi statement hai. Bohat hi soch kar ke aisa bole woh ke is ki niyat achi thi to is ka anjam bhi acha hoga. is ki niyat buri thi to is ka anjam bhi bura hoga. Yeh hai aur aap jante hain ke Bukhari ki pehli riwayat jo hai, pehli riwayat yahi hai innama al a'malu bin niyyat . Amal ka daromadar niyat par hai. Action depends upon intention. Yeh to bohat hi musallama aqeedah hai sare ulama ka.
1:02:57is mein koi ikhtilaf nahi hai. Maulana, agla sawal Delhi se kiya hai Mr. Sagar ne aur unhon ne likha hai What is the available, what is the amicable solution of political instability in Central Asia?