“Scholars have closed the doors of ijtihad. I want to know if common Muslims' thinking can be corrected even if their scholars' existing mentality and approach continues, and if correction in scholars' thinking is a precondition to improve the situation.”Asked by ادریس اور شبانہ, رائے پور
Maulana agla sawal Raipur se aya hai. Mr. Idrees aur Miss Shabana ne likha hai ke ulama have closed the doors of the ijtihad. I want to know if common muslims thinking be corrected even if their ulma existing mentality and approach continues. aur correction in ulama thinking is a precondition to improve the situation. bhai kaun sa masla hai is mein ulama poochte hain musalman. koi job ke liye business ke liye shadi ke liye jehez ke liye koi poochta hai?
isi mein koi shart lagai jaye. ji. ulama bilkul ineffective hain society mein koi in ka asar nahi hai bas kuch fatwa dete hain kuch bolte hain lekin asar kya hai? mujhe bataiye kaun aadmi hai aap is ko is ka naam bataye mujhe jo apne job ke liye ulama se poochta ho business ke liye ulama se poochta ho shadi mein jehez doon ke na doon is liye is ulama se poochta ho kuch nahi koi poochta nahi to is mein bhi koi aap excuse banate hain har aadmi ko khud padhna chahiye khud mutala karna chahiye aur quran ko hadith ko aur doosri kitabein jo hain us ko padh kar ke khud rai banaye woh kya sahi hai kya galat hai ulama to ineffective hain main nahi samajhta kisi bhi shobe mein in ka koi darja hai woh fatwa dete hain lekin manta kaun hai in ke fatwe ko.
Machine transcription. These are his recorded words, written down by software from the Urdu he speaks — so a line may carry a misheard word. Every timestamp above opens the video at that second: one tap and you can hear him say it. Quote it as speech, and link to the moment.