Concept of 'Insan-e-Kamil' and spiritual exercises
“Molana, who according to you is 'insan-e-kamil'? Can a spiritual exercise that is generally done in khanqahs produce insan-e-kamil? Or is it that without a mind-based or tadabbur-based spiritual exercise, it cannot be achieved?”Asked by Khalid Ansari, Noida
He answers at 15:40 in Islamic Pacifism Q&A · 2 min 7 sec
15:40agla sawal Maulana hai mister khalid ansari ka, noida se. unhon ne likha hai: "Molana, who according to you is insan-e-kamil? Can a spiritual exercise that is generally done in khanqahs produce insan-e-kamil? Or is it that without a mind-based or tadabbur-based spiritual exercise, it cannot be achieved?" dekhen, insan-e-kamil ka to lafz hi ek bid'at hai. na quran mein yeh lafz hai, na hadis mein yeh lafz hai. main samajhta hoon koi aadmi duniya mein insan-e-kamil ho nahi sakta hai. impossible hai. yani yeh target nahi hai ke hum insan-e-kamil banen.
16:30koi bhi mujhe hadith nahi maloom hai, koi bhi ayat nahi maloom hai jis mein yeh kaha gaya ho ke a logon, tum insan kamil bano. yeh jo log banaye hain, woh Quran o hadith se bahar apna nazariya unhon ne banaya hai. to ab ab sawal yeh hai ke woh khanqahi tareeqa kya hai? woh ek alag sawal hai. khanqahi tareeqa jo hai, mein us ko yani mein ne woh tareeqa nahi ikhtiyar kiya hai. is par meri kitab hai, tajdeed de sakta hoon ke yeh yeh jo concept hai insan kamil ka, woh ek bidat hai. kyun ke is dunya mein yeh mumkin nahi ke koi aadmi insan kamil ban jaye.
17:15yeh to fitnon ki dunya hai, yeh ibtila ki dunya hai, test ki dunya hai. to yeh mumkin nahi hai. sahaba ke halaat aap parhiye, kisi sahabi ko ke baray mein aap nahi payenge ke woh samajhta ho ke mein insan kamil ban gaya hoon. har aadmi yeh samajhta tha ke mein abhi insan naqis hoon. to mere meri study ke mutabiq yeh hai soorat e haal.
17:48Mr. Muhammad Ameeni ne Aligarh se sawal kiya hai. unhon ne likha hai: "Maulana sahib, aap ke nazdeek existence of God and existence of hereafter ka sab se bara argument kya hai?"