“The Khilafat movement started by Shaukat Ali and Muhammad Ali Jauhar was based on a wrong foundation, and every such movement is un-Islamic. Please comment.”Asked by Aamir bin Yusuf, Pakistan
maulana agla sawal aya hai mr amir bin yousaf ka pakistan se. unhon ne likha hai maulana shaukat ali aur muhammad ali johar ne jo tehreek khilafat shuru ki thi woh is ka matlab hai ke ghalat base par thi aur is tarah ki har tehreek un islamic hai. is ke bare mein maulana woh chahte hain aap kuch kahein. ghalat ka matlab hai ke be nateeja. ek to ghalat ka matlab hota hai ke sharab ghalat cheez hai, khinzir ghalat cheez hai. woh ek alag ghalat ka mafhoom hota hai. lekin tehreek ke bare mein main kahoon ga ke be nateeja tehreekein theen yeh. kuch is ka ballah nahi tha is par khamkhwah nare laga rahe hain khilafat ke.
to insani zindagi mein, samai zindagi mein woh kaam karna chahiye jis mein koi nateeja nikle, result oriented action. to main sirf yeh kehta hoon ke woh result oriented tareeqa nahi thi. woh jazbati tareeqe theen. taqreerein, jalsay, jaloos, hangami kya hua qissa khatam. main sirf yahi kehta hoon agar meri tehreeron ko le kar unhon ne aisa kaha ho to main sirf yeh kehta hoon ke yeh tehreekein result oriented nahi theen. maulana karachi se ek aur sawal aaya hai abhi. mister fazl amin ka hai. unhon ne likha hai ke main ek dukandar hoon.
Machine transcription. These are his recorded words, written down by software from the Urdu he speaks — so a line may carry a misheard word. Every timestamp above opens the video at that second: one tap and you can hear him say it. Quote it as speech, and link to the moment.