Accountability for good intention causing discord?
“If someone does a deed that causes discord in the Ummah, but his intention was good, will he be held accountable in the Hereafter? For example, some people gave a political interpretation to Islam.”Asked by Irshad Ali, Rampur
He answers at 36:32 in God Gives in Abundance · 3 min 3 sec
36:32Alhamdulillah, aap ki baaton se aur zyada dawat ka kaam karne ki inspiration mili hai. Jazak Allah." Khair, Maulana, agla sawal lete hain. Yeh sawal bheja hai Rampur se Irshad Ali sahib ne. Unhone likha hai: "Maulana, agar kisi se koi aisa kaam ho jaye jis se ummat mein bigaad paida ho jaye, Lekin uski niyat us kaam ko karne ki achhi thi, toh kya uski akhirat mein pakad hogi? Jaise ke kuch logon ne Islam ko political interpretation diya." Dekhein, hadith hai bahut hi mashhoor: "Innamal a'malu binniyat." Innamal a'malu binniyat yani haan, Allah ke haan har amal apni niyat ke aitbar se mana jata hai.
37:33Niyat jaise niyat hogi, uske lehaz se uska darja hoga. Misal ke taur par dekhiye, ek hadith hai bahut mashhoor ke ek badu ka oont gum ho gaya sehra mein, Sehra mein desert mein. Toh ab daud raha hai idhar udhar. Toh aap jante hain ke pehle zamane mein desert mein ek hi cheez hoti thi badu ke liye, woh uska oont. Oont, oont hai toh sab kuch hai, oont nahin hai toh kuch bhi nahin. Toh bechara badu daud raha hai idhar udhar, oont dhoondh raha hai, dhoondh raha hai. yahan tak ke achaanak woh dekhta hai ek jagah ke is ka oont khara hua hai. to is ki zubaan se nikla: "allahum anta abdi wa ana rabbuk." yaani khushi mein keh pada hua hai: "ae allah, tu mera banda hai, main tera rab hoon." is par us ko jannat de di gayi.
38:45to niyat, is ki niyat jo thi, woh bohat hi khair thi, bohat hi achi thi. to allah taala ke haan koi bhi dua apni niyat ke aitbaar se qabool hoti hai. niyat agar khair ho to is ka badla bhi khair hoga. maulana, kuch aur comment parhna chahenge. ah, mehboob bhai ne mumbai se likha hai: "maulana, whenever i meet you or listen to you, i become very energetic. such energy today also doubled in me after listening to today's talk." jazaak allah, maulana. maulana iqbal umri ne likha hai: "deen sara ka sara alhamdulillah par qaim hai.
39:35mayusi ka koi sawal nahi hai. maulana, sari ummat ke liye yahi ek paigham kafi hai." jazaak allah. ah, muhammad irfan rashidi sahib ne nagpur se likha hai: "maulana sahib, mera take away yeh hai ke humein allah ki rehmat se mayoos nahi hona chahiye." this inspires me a lot.