Does Islam allow rebellion for freedom?

maulana, agla sawal Dilli se hai Dr. Fareeda Khanam ka. unhon ne likha hai: "yesterday i was watching TV channel Aljazeera. one Egyptian lady who was with the protesters. was being asked by the reporter as to why she was with the protesters. she replied: 'i have a fancy home, i have a fancy car, but i don't enjoy freedom. my question is: does Islam allow to become a rebel to demand for freedom?'" bilkul yeh mere nazdeek toh haram hai. haram konsi freedom? kis cheez ko aap freedom kehte hain? kis cheez ko?

yeh yeh jo bol rahi hai, woh woh bhi toh freedom hai. yaani ek hukoomat qaim hai, is mein aap bol rahe hain, yeh yeh bhi toh freedom hai. mein is ko galat samajhta hoon ke un ko freedom nahi thi. pehle bhi thi aur ab bhi hai. jis cheez ki freedom, yaani Islam ka tasawwur jo yeh hai ke aap aap Islam mein jo summum bonum hai, freedom nahi hai, woh hai peace. yeh western concept hai ke woh freedom ko summum bonum maante hain. unlimited freedom Islam ka tasawwur yeh nahi hai.

Islam ki tozeeq agar aap ko mawaqe ko avail karne ka opportunity khuli hui hai, is mein aap ko koi rukawat nahi hai, toh wahi freedom Islam ke nazdeek kaafi hai. jaise hum India mein dekhiye, hum ko hum India mein daawati kaam kar rahe hain, koi rukawat nahi. hum ko theek yahi mauqa Misr mein pehle bhi tha aur ab bhi tha. toh konsa freedom woh chahti hai? jo freedom woh chahti hai, woh Islam mein matloob hi nahi hai. toh mein dekh yeh ek bilkul galat baat hai, baseless baat hai ke un ko freedom nahi mili hui. freedom na hoti toh un ke paas car bhi na hoti, un ke paas ghar bhi na hota, bol bhi nahi sakti thi woh.

mein toh samajhta hoon ke yeh is tarah ki jo baatein yeh log bol rahe hain, yaani ke woh jaante hi nahi ke freedom kya hai aur ghulami kya hai. bas ek ek josh mein bol rahe hain, bas kuch bekhabari, bekhabar hain har cheez se. woh maulana, agla sawal hai Shahnawaz Zafar sahib ka Dilli se. unhon ne aap se poocha hai: "please guide about nationalism in the light of Islamic teachings.