Why Muslim Brotherhood Failed in Egypt?

maulana, agla sawal lahore pakistan se hai muhammad sajjad sahib ka. unhone likha hai: "After a long struggle, Muslim brotherhood came into power in Egypt through democratic process. Why is it that they were unable to prevail their government? Can 'army coup' be justified in Egypt?" dekhiye, yeh 'army coup' ka maamla nahin hai. khud murshid sahib, yaani doctor muhammad morsi, ne apni taqreer jo depose kiye jaane se pehle ki thi, unhone khud kaha tha, mein ne suna hai internet par, aap bhi sun sakte hain ke "أصفت أهانًا وأخطأت أهانًا أخرى" ۔ mein ne kuch sahi kiya, kuch ghalat kiya. achha, ghalat kiya hai, us mein unhone yeh point out nahin kiya ke ghalat mein ne kiya. yeh to maana unhone ke mein ne ghalti ki.

"أصفت أهانًا وأخطأت أهانًا أخرى" ۔ to yeh nahin bataya ke unhone ghalti kiya ki. lekin mein ne jo tajziya kiya hai waqeaat ka, to ghalati yeh thi, ghalati yeh thi ke yeh log democracy ka naam lete hain, aur saare musalmanon ka haal yahi hai, lekin democratic culture ko nahin jaante. woh these people don't know what is democratic culture. dekhiye, democratic culture kya hai? fareeqe sani ki rai ko accept karna, fareeqe sani ki baat ko accept karna. kyunke democracy hamesha ek acquisition opposition rehti hai.

yani wahan par Ali khawar al musalmoon jo thay, woh ghalib hue to 32 feesad ko vote miley thay. bas 32 feesad. is ka matlab hai ke ek bari tadad woh thi jo jo ke un ke khilaf thi, aur un ko absolute majority bhi nahi mili thi. un ko ab absolute majority nahi mili thi. to is ke matlab hai ke ek tadad thi opposition ki, woh more than 50 feesad thi. woh log to democracy mein kya hota hai ke aap ko accept karna parta hai opposition ki. opposition ko aap, yani hukoomat ki seat par baithe hain, tab bhi wahan pe ek opposition hai.

unhon ne opposition ko bilkul, yani khater bhi nahi laye. nahi laye. murshid sahib aise ahkam jari kiye jaise ke un ki koi haqeeqat nahi, bas hum sab kuch hain. to main ne ek ek article likha tha, us mein us mein main ne yeh yeh baat likhi thi ke musalman jo hain, woh sirf kingship model ko jante hain, democratic model ko musalman nahi jante. dekhiye, dono mein farq kya hai? kingship model jo hai, woh is ka jo equation hai, woh ruler aur ruled ka hai. yani ruler aur ruled ke equation par khara hota hai kingship model.

lekin democracy mein aisa nahi hai. democracy mein jo equation hai, woh hai people aur representative of people, yani awam aur numaindagan awam. to yeh log nahi jante is baat ko. woh samajhte hain ke bas hum ruler hain, woh ruled hain, hum hakim hain, woh mahkoom hain. isi zehan ke sath unhon ne chaha ke hukoomat chalayein, woh aur fail ho gaye. woh

main bohat kaafi mein is ko parhta raha hoon, yeh is phenomena ko jo Misr ka jo hai, in logon ka jo model, un ka jo mindset tha, jo un ka, jo un ka, jo un ka mindset tha, jo sadiyon se bana hua hai, woh wohi hai. hakim aur mahkoom ke ek equation base karta hai. woh woh jo equation hai ke ek taraf people hain, doosri taraf people ke numaindagan hain, is is ko jante hi nahi. woh to opposition ko accept nahi karte. to jab unhon ne jab Bani Israel ka yeh qaul ke "أخطأت أهانًا أخرى" . to main ne kaha ke dekhiye, yeh jante nahi ke democracy mein aap mistake ko afford nahi kar sakte.

you cannot afford to commit a mistake in democracy. kyun? wahan pe opposition baithi hui hai, woh is woh is intezar mein hai ke aap koi ghalti karein, us ko exploit kare. woh democracy mein hamesha ek opposition hoti hai jo is intezar mein rehti hai ke aap koi opposition, ke aap koi ghalti karein, woh us ko exploit kare. kyun? us ko agle term mein us ko jeetna hai election. kingship nahi hai ke jo badshah ho, butt ke gaya to 50 baras akela wohi badshahi karta rahega.

democracy mein to char baras, panch baras mein badalti hai hukoomat. to opposition ko agle election us ke samne hota hai, agley election ke liye us ko maidan hamwar karna hai. to ruling party ko bohat ziyada mohtat rehna chahiye ke aisi koi ghalti woh na kare jis ko opposition exploit kar sake. yeh sab kiya doctor murshi sahib ne. to ab unhon ne jo jo ek baat aur main arz karunga ke is mein western countries ki ghalti yeh hai ke unhon ne Arab dunya mein democracy ko export karna chaha, jis ko kehte thay woh Arab Spring. Arab Spring matlab tha ke western tribe ki democracy jo hai, us ko export kar ke laya jaye Arab mein.

lekin un ki ghalati yeh thi ke woh jante nahi the ke arab mind jo hai, us ko accept karne ki tayari nahi. arbon ki jo training hai, un ka jo education hai, woh democracy pe base hi nahi karti. woh to kingship model par jee rahe hain aaj tak. yani arab dunya jo hai, woh aaj tak kingship model ko liye hue hai. democratic model se woh woh familiar nahi hain. to un logon ne chaha ke woh nahi, nahi, yani western mind ki democracy ko, western type ki democracy ko export karen.

to woh export nahi ho saki. woh woh revolt kar diya. bhai, yeh yeh hai sara qissa misr ka. maulana, agla sawal doctor safina tabassum ka hai, ajmer se. unhon ne likha hai: "maulana, how can we confirm to ourselves that we have discovered the role meant for us by god?" is ke bare mein bataen.