Why good die early and bad live long

maulana, agla sawal aya hai, unhon ne location nahin likhi hai. un ka naam hai mister ghaus muhammad sahib. unhon ne likha hai ke maulana sahib, "why do good people die early and bad live long? why is this so ?" yeh to hai nahin, kahan hai yeh? yeh to koi baat nahin hai. yeh kahan bhi? hum to nahin jante aisa. yeh to ek mufrada hai. aisa aisi kehte hain log, aise hi. lekin aisa waqea to nahin hai. yeh to khilaf waqea baat hai. ek adha admi hai, asal mein logon ka mizaj hai ke generalize karna.

ek admi agar mar gaya, farz kiye to us ko generalize karenge. dekho, bhai itna acha admi tha, jaldi mar gaya. bura admi ki lambi umar ho gayi to dekho, bhai itni lambi is ki umar hui. it is severe generalization. aisi rah nahin banayi ja sakti. yani kaun sa survey aap ne kiya hai ke sari duniya mein jo achhe hain, wahi jaldi marte hain aur sari duniya bure hain, wahi der der marte hain? aisa to koi aisa koi survey nahin kiya gaya hai kabhi, na aisi koi aisa aisa koi woh hai. aisi koi nahin, koi ilm aisa nahin hai jo is tarah ki survey kar ke hum ko bata raha ho. yeh to ek kuch awam mein chali hui baaten hain.

maulana, agla sawal gulbarga se aya hai, muhammad abdul gani sahib ka. unhon ne likha hai: "prophet ke companions ke liye jo reward allah ne rakha, kya woh hamare liye bhi applicable hai?"