To what extent should we remain silent

maulana, agla sawal aaya hai kashmir se mr hilal ahmad ka. unhone likha hai ke "i am very impressed with you right from my very childhood when i was in class seventh. i am a continuous reader of your books and monthly al-uswa. most of the times you talk about patience and non-violence. but i want to ask you something: to what extent we will keep mum? to what extent we will keep mum? hum kab tak chup rahenge? kis extent tak? what will you do when somebody will come and kill your dear ones?

example in kashmir: what will you do when somebody will come from outside and will throw you away from your home? example in palestine: what will you do when your brothers would be put behind the bars for years together for no reason? what will you do when somebody will abuse your mother in front of your eyes? maulana, after all, we are human beings, not angels. everything has a limit. please do explain. dekhiye, is mein sab se badi ghalati jo hai, woh ek hai ke without reason. yeh fallacy hai, fallacy. yeh main aap ko palestine aur kashmir ki misaal deta hoon.

yeh saari duniya jhoot bhi jeeti hai, jhoot bhi jeeti hai. palestine mein kya hua? 1948 mein partition hua. partition mein lines chair mila tha arbon ko. unhone inkar kar diya ke hum nahi lete, aur ladai shuru kar di unhone ke hum sarami ko full bahar, hum tum ko thuke denge samandar mein. toh unhone shuru kiya, woh badu ko, woh bol raha hai. toh jab unhone jawab diya, retaliation ko woh samajhte hain ke woh action tha har jagah, yani israel react kar, retaliate karta hai. toh zahir hai ke woh kyun nahi? aap pathar marenge, woh goli marega. aap ne kaha ke tum ko hum palestine mein nahi rehne denge, toh samandar mein thuke denge.

unhone kaha ke hum tum ko thuke lenge. yeh without reason mamla nahi hai. yeh reason paida kiya aap ne, accept na kar ke. ab kya hai? ab kuch bhi nahi un ke paas hai. kashmir mein dekhiye, 1989 se pehle, yani october 1989 mein wahan military shuru hui. uske pehle peace tha, mukammal peace tha. main bar bar gaya hoon kashmir mein. jhoot hai, agar koi kahe ke is se pehle wahan kuch hota tha. sar tabah jhoot hai. lekin jab aap ne bomb mara toh wahi marenge. kaise nahi marenge? woh jo kuch hua hai, yeh yeh sab retaliation hai. kashmir mein retaliation hai, palestine mein retaliation hai.

aap kehte hain without reason, khula hua reason maujood hai dono jagah. quran majeed mein hai, dekhiye, surah woh saba ka qissa ke malika saba jo thi, usko unka woh mila letter hazrat sulaiman ka, jo king the, ke tum surrender karo, nahi toh hum apni fauj le kar aa jayenge. toh

us ne apne durbariyon se mashwara kiya. durbariyon ne kaha ke nahi, hum laren ge. to malika saba ne kaha ke nahi, laren ge to woh woh gating evil hoga hamare liye. kyunke is ne quran majeed mein ayat hai is silsile mein ke "in al muluk dakhil afsadu wa jalu ahl azlat". yani wahi jo aap keh rahe hain ke wahan hua, wahi is ne kaha ke yeh ho gaya "wa kadhalik yafalun". woh bhi aise hi karenge, yani agarche woh paighambar hain, tab bhi yahi karenge. to is ne kiya kiya? musalehat kar li. to aap larr rahe hain, woh kehte hain ke is ka hum ko prize na deni pare, chahe falasteen ho, chahe kashmir ho, har jagah musalman apni military ki prize de rahe hain, peace ki prize nahi de rahe.

ghalti, yeh ghalt, bohat bari ghalat fehmi hai, bohat bari, yani yani woh hai felasi hai. kya aap samajhte hain ke yak tarfa ho raha hai? yeh na falasteen mein yak tarfa hai, na kashmir mein yak tarfa hai. woh to retaliation hai. jab tak arab peace par thay, to unhein peace mila hua tha. jab unhon ne military shuru kar di, to unhein military mil rahi hai. aise kashmir mein hua to kaisi ajeeb baat hai ke musalman is raat ko bhi nahi jaan sake ke jo kuch ho raha hai, without reason nahi ho raha hai. woh to retaliation ho raha hai. aur main bilashuba is mein samajhta hoon ke is mein, is mein jo hai, musalmanon ko reassessment ka time hai.

is qism ki baatein karne ka time nahi hai. agar woh reassessment nahi karenge to phir yeh silsila jaari rahega. yeh duniya dekhiye, duniya mein har aadmi ko azadi hai. aap kisi azadi ki abalish nahi kar sakte. to aap karenge to woh bhi karega. woh kyun nahi karega? bataiye. jab aap ne October 89 mein military shuru ki kashmir mein, to kya samajhte hain ke arab bhi chup chap baithe rahenge? woh kyun nahi shuru karenge? woh bhi karenge. jo aap ke paas hai, woh aap karenge. woh jo woh karenge. yeh bilkul hi ghalt hai yeh soch ke without reason ho raha hai. yeh har giz aisa nahi ho raha hai. woh bator retaliation ka ho raha hai. isi cheez ko samajhne mein masle ka hal hai.

jo jo log is ko na samjhein, to kabhi masla hal nahi kar sakenge. maulana inayatullah umri ka bangalore se sawal aaya hai. unhon ne likha hai: "jamhooriyat ko is islam ki matlooba cheez kyun samajhte nahi hain?