Reason for Avoiding Reasoning in Religion
“There are many Muslims who are very rational in secular matters. Still, they don't want to use reasoning in the matters of religion. What can be the reason of this behavior?”Asked by Safina Tabassum, Ajmer
He answers at 49:59 in Living in Falsehood · 2 min 30 sec
49:59So I am a great advocate of peace. Maulana, agla sawal Ajmer se hai Dr. Safina Tab Sim ka. Unhon ne likha hai: "Moulana, there are many Muslims who are very rational in secular matters. Still, they don't want to use reasoning in the matters of religion. What can be the reason of this behavior? main ne arz kiya isi ko ke hadith jo hai ke rasool Allah ne farmaya ke talab al ilm farizah ala kull muslim ilm seekhna har musalman par farz hai.
50:41to is ko ilm deen ke mani mein le liya. to deen mein ab reason ko apply nahi karna hai. deen ko doosri cheezon apply karo, deen ko deen mein kuch nahi. halankeh dekhen, main aap ko ek ayat yaad dilata hoon. quran mein hai ke pahadon ke bare mein, pahadon ke bare mein minbar al jibal jo al dan bid al humr mukhtalif anwaruhu wa aghraww basud innama yakhsh Allah min ibadihi al ulama is ka matlab hai ke ilm wale hi darte hain Allah se. to yahan ilm se murad kya hai? ilm al jibal, pahadon ka ilm. yahan is ayat se sabit hota hai ke agar aap ko agar pahadon ka ilm ho to aap ke andar Allah ka dar paida hoga. ab is ko aap generalize kijiye to agar nature ka ilm ho, agar aap ka nature ka ilm ho to aap ke andar Allah ka khauf paida hoga.
51:45ke aap clear taur par dekhen, yahan par yani yani jo jin cheezon ko jo mahdood mani mein liye hain, rakhe hain logon ne deen ke, us se bahar ki cheezon ka ilm bataya ja raha hai. to ek galat yani cheez phail gayi hai musalmanon mein ke deen ke mamle mein aql nahi, doosri cheezon mein aql istemal karo. to log job mein, apne business mein, apne family affairs mein reason ko apply karte hain aur jahan deen ka masla aaya hai, bas fatwa, fatwa, fatwa. yeh bilkul hi wrong hai, bilkul galat hai. is ka islam se koi talluq nahi.
52:30maulana, agla sawal tamil nadu se hai maulana iqbal um