Dissent in religion versus secular world
“Maulana, you said dissent is good as it helps in one's intellectual development. This is the reason West did very well and progressed very fast. My question is that dissent works to advantage in the secular world, but what about religious world? Would you say in religion also dissent is beneficial? As today we see that dissent quickly leads to violence and culminates to terrorism. What is your opinion on this?”Asked by Zubair Iqbal, Moradabad
He answers at 51:32 in Creative Thinking · 2 min 8 sec
51:32Maulana sahib, agla sawal bheja hai Zubair Iqbal sahib ne Muradabad se, aur unhon ne likha hai: "Maulana, you said dissent is good as it helps in one's intellectual development. This is the reason West did very well and progressed very fast. My question is that dissent works to advantage in the secular world, but what about religious world? Would you say in religion also dissent is beneficial? As today we see that dissent quickly leads to violence and culminates to terrorism. What is your opinion on this? " musalmanon ki kamzori yeh hai ke woh tolerance kho diya, unhon ne tolerance to hai hi nahin.
52:21woh jante hi nahin sachi baatein, woh jante hi nahin ke kisi issue par peaceful discussion karen, yeh jante hi nahin. woh debate karna jante hain, violence karna jante hain, ghussa hona jante hain. koi issue agar paida ho aur us par peaceful discussion karen, aap that leads to intellectual development, yeh
52:48musalman jante nahin. isi ko batana hai musalmanon ko, yeh batana hai ke jab bhi koi aap ki rai se alag rai zahir kare to ghussa mat huiye, peaceful andaaz mein us se discuss kijiye to khud aap hi ko faida hoga, aap ka zehni irtaqa hoga, aap ko neeli ibadat samajh mein aayegi.
53:14yehi baat musalmanon ko batai nahin gayi hai, sach poochhiye to musalmanon ka case unawareness ka case hai. masjido mein, madarson mein, jalson mein yeh baat batai nahin gayi thi. to hum chahte hain ke yeh process shuru ho, musalmanon ko bataya jaye, un ki unawareness toda jaye to sab theek ho jaye ga.
53:40maulana, agla sawal lene se pehle ek comment parhna chahenge jo bheja hai shafi ahmed dar sahib