“I am of the opinion that we should always take the advice or fatwa from living scholars rather than refer to those who are not alive.”Asked by Hamid Ansari, Bangalore
maulana, agla sawal bangalore se kiya hai hamid ansari sahib ne aur unhon ne likha hai: maulana sahib i am of the opinion that we should always take the advice or fatwa from living scholars rather than refer to those who are not alive. am i correct in this thinking?
pata nahi kya matlab hai, is sawal ka matlab hi meri samajh nahi hai. aap dekhiye, is tarah ki baat jab aap kahhen to aap ko specific language mein kehna chahiye. specific language, yeh jo aap ne sawal kiya, yeh non-specific language mein hai. to main jab sawal ka jawab hi nahi samajh raha hoon to kya jawab dun is ka? sawal
ka tareeqa yeh hai ke aap sawal ko hona chahiye specific language mein taake mujeeb samjhe ke sawal karne wale ka mudda kya hai. ji maulana, agla sawal lete hain jo chandigarh se kashif sahib ne likha hai.
Machine transcription. These are his recorded words, written down by software from the Urdu he speaks — so a line may carry a misheard word. Every timestamp above opens the video at that second: one tap and you can hear him say it. Quote it as speech, and link to the moment.