Prophet's Debate and Mubahala

maulana, agla sawal doctor farida khanoom ne bheja hai dilli se aur unhon ne likha hai ke there are some people who say that the prophet of islam himself engaged in debate; they give the example of mubahala to prove their point is ke baray mein batayen. dekhen, yeh galat reference hai, aisa reference dena gunah hai.

mubahala ki ayat surah aal imran mein hai, aap is ko parh sakte hain. to yeh madine mein, madine mein kuch najran ke isai aaye the, un ke sath aisa hua tha. to woh log rasool Allah ki baat ko tayyar nahin hote the ke aap rasool hain aur wohi rasool hain jis ki paish goi babal mein ki gayi thi.

to rasool Allah ne kaha theek hai, tum mannay ko tayyar nahin ho to mubahala karo. mubahala ka matlab yeh tha ke rasool Allah niklein apne ghar walon ko sath le kar, woh jo the, jo aaye the, us isai, woh niklein apne logon ke liye aur aik maidan mein ikatha hon aur dono yeh kahein ke hum mein se jo shakhs jhoota ho, us ko Khuda halak kar de.

to rasool Allah apne ghar ko aur fatima ko, ali ko le kar ke nikle aur wahan maidan mein gaye. lekin lekin jo isai log the, woh wahan nahin aaye, woh dar gaye. to yeh aakhri hujjatt ke taur par rasool Allah ne kiya tha, is ka koi talluq debate se nahin hai, yeh bilkul irrelevant reference hai yeh.

aur is tarah ka mubahala phir ummat ne kabhi kisi ne nahin kiya. ulama ka fatwa hai ke mubahala sirf peghambar ke liye tha, hamare liye nahin hai. to awwal to mubahala debate nahin tha aur doosra mubahala jo tha, sirf peghambar ke liye tha. to yeh bilkul yani irrelevant reference hai aur is qism ka reference kabhi dena nahin chahiye.

molana, agla sawal pakistan se miss shabana ansari ne kiya hai aur unhon ne likha hai ke molana,