Contradiction between reason and scholars' stance
“If reason is God's greatest gift and the Quran addresses reason, why do our scholars say that reason has no place in Islam, causing common Muslims to not dare to use their reason regarding the Quran?”Asked by Shah Nawaz Zafar, Delhi
He answers at 47:57 in Study of The Quran · 1 min 46 sec
47:57Maulana, agla sawal Dilli se hai Shahnawaz Zafar Sahab ka, aur unhon ne likha hai: "aql insaan ke liye Allah ki taraf se sab se qeemti tohfa hai, aur Allah insaan ko aik aisi kitab de hi nahi sakta jo us ki aql ko address na kar sake ya us ki aql ke daire se bahar ki baat karta ho. magar hamare ulama yeh kehte hain ke Islam mein aql ka koi dakhal nahi, aur yahi wajah hai ke aam musalman Quran ke muamle mein apni aql ka istemal karne ki jurrat nahi kar paate. meharbani kar ke wazahat karen. bhai, is ka jawab to main ne de diya ke woh jo tafseer bil rai ke baray mein jo hadith hai, us ka ghalat interpretation.
48:54yani tafseer bil rai mein mana kiya gaya tha ke bila tayari ke, baghair jaane boojhe, yun hi bas bol rahay hain, stage par kharay ho kar ke. is se mana kiya gaya. baqi jahan tak is baat ka hai ke tehqeeq karen aap, aap arabi zaban seekhen, dua karen, aur phir poori, yani Allah ke Allah ke samne apne ko responsible samajhte rahiye, us ke mafhoom tak pohnchne ki koshish karen. yeh to bilkul aane matloob hai.
49:31to is hadith ka main samajhta hoon ke ghalat matlab le kar ke yeh zehan bana hai. Maulana, agla sawal Bangalore se hai Farhad Sahab ka, aur unhon ne likha hai: "Molana, recent reports have revealed that many youths from India have gone to join ISIS, and they claim that they are doing it for the cause of Allah.