Issue of Insulting the Prophet

assalamu alaikum wa rahmatullahi. aaj hum sab se pehla sawal apne, aah, mehman Maulana Fayyazuddin Umri sahab se karenge: "shatm-e-rasool" ka masla kya hai? is par aap hamein kuch bataen. bismillah hir rahman nir rahim. wa salallahu ala nabiyyi al-karim, wa ala aalihi wa sahbihi ajmaeen. amma ba'd. sab se pehle Maulana Farhad sahab, main aap ka shukr guzar hoon ke aap ne is session mein hamein invite kiya, aur ek burning topic par kuch alfaaz maujooda hamare sam'een ke samne rakhne ke ka mauqa diya, jazakumullah.

aap ke sawal par aane se pehle ek martaba hum sab jo hain, rasool-e-akram sallallahu alaihi wasallam ka jo hum par ehsan hai, usko yaad karen, aur rasool-e-akram aur aap ke ashaab par hazaron hazar durood o salam ho, jinhon ne alam-e-insaniyat ke liye be-hisab sacrifices di, aur khuda ke creation plan aur khuda ki aakhri kitab ko insanon tak pahunchane mein aakhri struggle kar di. ab hum aate hain aap ke is sawal par ke "shatm-e-rasool" ka masla kya hai? shatm ek arabi zaban ka lafz hai jis ko agar aap simple english mein kehna chahen to aap keh sakte hain "abusing". shatm-e-rasool ka matlab hua "abusing of the prophet Muhammad" aur "other prophets". aam zaban mein aap kahenge peghambar-e-islam ke mamle mein gustakhi.

to is ko kehte hain aam taur par musalman shatm rasool. is masle se hum, jahan tak meri memory kaam kar rahi hai, eighty, nineteen eighty eight se main waqif hoon, jabke main bohat hi aik, aah, apne teenage mein tha, jab main hifz kar raha tha. to us waqt maine sab se pehli martaba apne, aah, khateeb sahab ko masjid mein juma ke din, aah, woh bohat hi zyada furious thay aur bohat hi furious speeches de rahe thay khutbe mein, khutbe mein juma ke. to main to teenage mein rehne ki wajah se kuch samajh nahi paya tha. baad mein main sochta hoon to ghaliban jo hai woh "Satanic Verses" jo Salman Rushdie sahab ne likhi thi, is kitab par unka woh radd amal chal raha tha. main us waqt jo hai itna us ko ghor se samajh nahi paya. main us waqt quran ke hifz ka talib-e-ilm tha. to, aah, ab main jab apne forties mein hoon to mujhe lagta hai ke yeh masla kitna gumabheer hai aur kitna dunya mein jo hai muslim community aur doosri communities ke liye aik disturbing issue ban chuka hai.

to aaiye, aah, is issue ki jar kya hai, main wo baat bata kar apni aap ke is sawal ke jawab ko finish karunga. hamare Islamic literature mein is issue ki root cause maujood hain. is silsile mein agar aap hamare Islami literature ka mutala karein to teen kitabein is silsile mein likhi gayi hain. sab se mashhoor kitab jo aam taur par logon ke andar mutadawil hai, aah, commonly used hai, woh kitab hai Ibn Taymiyyah ki. doosri is silsile mein mashhoor kitab hai, aah, Allama Subki ki.

aur teesri mashhoor kitab hai Allama Ibn Abidin Shami ki. to shatm rasool ke masle mein ghaliban jo hai in kitabon ne jo hai basic role play kiya hai. aur musalmanon mein yeh misconception phaila diya ke shatm jo hai aik bohat hi blasphemous activity hai jis ka hum bohat hi violently react karna chahiye. to ghaliban yahi woh kitabein hain jis mein ulama ke, aah, aqwal ko, ulama ki opinions ko collect kiya gaya hai. goya ke woh collection of opinions of fatwas hain, fatwas of Muslim ulama . to is kitab ke andar aap dekhenge to jo hai teeno musannifeen is had tak jaane ki koshish karte hain ke woh jo hai blasphemy ko, aah, is, aah, minor level par le jaane ki koshish karte hain ke agar kisi ne Amna ka yateem bhi kaha Rasool Allah ke bare mein, aah, aur fan of, aah,

bibi Amna h, yeh bhi agar kisi ne kaha to woh jo hai blasphemous act kiya aur us ko jo hai us par qatl kiya jayega. to aksar logon ne yahi likha hai ke us ko qatl hi kiya jayega agarche ke woh tauba bhi kar le. aah, la yastatab. woh kehte hain ke tauba karega tab bhi jo hai us ko qatl hi kiya jayega. aah, bohat sare ulama ki yeh is mein rai batai gayi hai. aah, woh kehte hain ke jo hai kisi ne agar crime kiya hai aur tauba kiya to tauba karne ki wajah se jaise us ki chori ka gunah maaf nahi kiya jata hai, isi tarah jo hai shatm jo hai isi tarah ka aik masla hai.

aur is par jo hai kabhi is ko maaf nahi kiya jayega, chahe to Khuda hashr ke din us ko maaf kar de. to ghaliban jo hai yahin se woh extremism jo hai musalmanon ne extract kiya hai in kitabon se jo collection of fatwas hain. basically woh kitabein apne aap mein koi, aah, mustaqil kitab nahi hai. is mein, aah, sab woh hamare ulama ke jo hai opinions ko collect kiya gaya jin mein se majority yahi kehti hai ke jo hai qatl kiya jayega. agarche ke is mein kuch exceptional statement bhi hai jaise Imam Abu Hanifa kehte hain ke us ko qatl nahi kiya jayega. kyunke woh kehte hain ke jo hai jab shatm Khuda par koi saza nahi hai hamare scholars ke paas to shatm rasool par kaisi saza? aah, isi tarah jo hai Sufyan Suri aur bohat sare logon ki rai hai ke nahi kiya jayega lekin woh bohat hi aik, aah, minority group of ulama hain.

baqi jo hai zyada tar ulama ki yahi rai hai aur woh is is extreme tak pahunch chuke hain ke jo hai, aah, agar us ne tauba ki tab bhi us ko nahi choda jayega, us ko qatl hi kiya jayega. to ghaliban jo hai meri is explanation se is masle ki gumabheerta aur jo hai, aah, importance jo hai hamare samne aa gaya hoga. to main aap ka shukriya ada karta hoon ke aap ne aik bohat achhe sawal par guftagu karne ka hamein mauqa diya. haan, bohat achhi baat aap ne batai ke yeh kis buniyad par musalmanon ke darmiyan yeh masla itna sensitive ho gaya hai, woh teen kitabein hain.

to is talluq se main apne sunne walon ko yeh batana chahta hoon ke Maulana Wahiduddin Khan sahab ne apni kitab "Shatm-e-Rasool" ka masla jo maine aap ke samne zikr kiya tha, us mein, aah, unhone specially Ibn Taymiyyah ki kitab ko le kar tajziya kiya aur bataya ke un ke jo dalail hain woh kya hain, kis, kahan par ja kar woh, aah, aah, leak karte hain. aah, waqai woh daleel honi chahiye ya nahi, yeh cheez is mein aap jaan sakte hain is ko parh kar. to ab mein apna agla sawal Maulana Inayat Umri sahib se karunga ke kya peghambar e Islam sallallahu alaihi wasallam ne shatm e rasool ki saza kisi ko di thi?