Which Opinion on Daba is Final
“I read the January 2013 issue of Al-Risala; it opened my eyes. Now Doomsday seems right in front of me. My colleagues are asking: Regarding Daba, Al-Risala has previously published three different opinions from you. Should we consider the current opinion as final, or should we also accept the previous opinions as correct? Please guide us.”Asked by ڈاکٹر قمر خان, علی گڑھ
He answers at 1:09:54 in Importance of Peace · 3 min 38 sec
1:09:54maulana, agla sawal aligarh se hai doctor qamar khan sahab ka. unhon ne likha hai: "maulana sahab, jannvari 2013 ka al-risala parha, is se meri aankhen khul gayin. ab domz de bilkul samne nazar aa raha hai. hamare saathi ye kveshchan kar rahe hain ke daba ke bare mein al-risala mein is se pehle maulana ki teen alag alag raayen aa chuki hain. kya hum maujooda raay ko final samjhen ya saath saath is se pehle wali raay ko bhi sahi manen? pliz hamein gaid kijiye." dekhiye, daba jo hai, daba ka mamla ye hai ke Quran se ye sabit hota hai ke daba niklega. hadithon mein hai ke daba niklega,
1:10:47lekin koi aadmi bilkul ta'ayyun ke sath nahi keh sakta ke daba kya cheez hai. hadith mein jo tafsilat hain, us ko muhaddiseen ne khud radd kar diya hai. is se kahaniyan bohat sari hain daba ke bare mein. is ko jo raste ulama hain, wo nahi mante. to daba jo hai, ek ek ek explenation ka mozu hai. wo aisa nahi hai ke ke hadith mein aaya hai ke panch waqt namaz padho to aap panch waqt namaz padhne lagen. to main ye manunga ke ab jo main ne likha hai, wahi wahi meri taza tehqeeq hai. ab jo likha hai maine, aur dekhein, is qism ke farq to hote hi hain. yani saare ulama ke haan, yeh saare ulama ke haan aisa hi hai.
1:11:38yani aap jante hain ke imam ghazali ki kitab hai "al-munqidh min al-zalal", gumrahi se nikalne wala. apne bare mein bataya ke main pehle gumrahi mein tha, ab nikal kar aaya hoon. ek kitab hai baqayda "al-munqidh min al-zalal" ki. maulana saif nadvi ne baqayda ek mazmoon likha tha "rujoo aur eteraaf". kuch cheezon ko unhon ne kaha tha ke main is ko rujoo karta hoon. jo main ne kaha tha, woh theek nahi tha. to yeh to ulama ka ek process hai. khud paighambaron ke haan bhi aisa hota hai. ab is wajah se ke paighambar jo hai, woh is se khali hai. rasool allah sallallahu alaihi wasallam ne se poocha gaya tha rasool allah sallallahu alaihi wasallam se ke mushrikeen ki aulad ka kya anjaam hoga aakhirat mein?
1:12:19aap ne farmaya ke "hum ma abahum", yani mushrikeen jo khud jahan jayenge, wohin un ke bachche bhi jayenge. baad ko aap ne kaha ke nahi, yeh farishte hamein yeh bataya hai, aisa nahi hoga. to phir aap ne bataya ke doosri baat kahi. aap ne unhon ne kaha ke "hum khadam ahl al-jannah", ahl-e-jannat ke khadim ho gaye. to is se aap ko pareshani, pareshani kyun hoti hai? kai log mujhe aisa sawal karte hain, kyun pareshani hoti hai? aap logon ko yeh ghair-elmi baat hai. yeh pareshani jo hoti hai, woh ghair-elmi baat hai.
1:12:56aakhri baat ko aap baghair poochhe hue, aakhri baat ko aap le lijiye. yeh sawal kyun karte hain? aap yeh sawal karna ghair-elmi zehan ki nishani hai. aakhri baat ko maan lijiye, bas baat khatam. jaise rasool allah sallallahu alaihi wasallam ke baad wale ban ko maan lijiye, aap us ke liye cook pass karte hain ke pehle koi aisa koi kaha tha. yeh koi sahi "it is not good sign". kai log aise sawalat karte hain, aise aise nahi, nahi, nahi. yeh kyun is mein uljhe rehte hain? un ke dimagh mein yeh samajh nahi aata.
1:13:33maulana, agla sawal kashmir se hai shafi ahmed dar sahab ka. unhon ne likha hai: "maulana sahab, my question is about nasa prediction: will the world end on 21 december 2012 because the winter solstice is aligned with the milky way or because of the end of the mayan calendar?"