Did Muslim Reaction Increase Curiosity for Film?
“Times of India says: "Had Muslims not reacted violently, very few people would have watched the film. Not only has it increased people's curiosity, but now YouTube plans to put the complete video online." What are your thoughts on this?”Asked by Farida Khanam, Delhi
He answers at 1:20:07 in Creative Solution or Ijtihadi Hal · 6 min 37 sec
1:20:07maulana, agla sawal dilli se hai doctor farida khanam ka. unhon ne likha hai ke maulana, yeh jo abhi present violence hua hai movie ko le ke, to is mein unhon ne likha hai ke times of india mein aaya hai ke "head muslims not reacted violently, very few people would have watch the film. not only has it increased the curiosity of people, but now youtube plans to put the complete video on line." maulana, what is your thoughts on in this? yeh to
1:20:39bohat sahi baat hai. maine hi padha hai wiedia ke is is report ko. yeh to musalman, maine thoda sa dekha internet par, thoda sa dekha hai is ko. itna absurd hai woh bilkul, yaani itni theme is ki fazool hai ke woh is qabil nahin ke koi dekhe der tak. is ko aadmi is ko zara sa dekhe ga, is ke baad chhod de ga. is ko yeh to musalman ne shorgon bachaya, shorgon bachaya to is ki ahmiyat paida kar di. shorgon bacha ke yahi baat hui thi salman rushdie ke muamle mein ke woh kitaab bhi bilkul is ki theme bohat thi, third class ki theme hai is ki.
1:21:24aur lekin wahan jo shor bachaya hai, tab logon ko khwab hi kya ke is ko padho, kya baat hai is kitaab mein. to salman rushdie ke muamle mein bhi musalmanon ne shorgor kar ke is ki ahmiyat badha di. aise hi is baar bhi shorgor kar ke is ki ahmiyat badha di. warna koi bhi shakhs is kitaab ko padhe ya is ah yeh innocent substance ko dekhe, itna zyada laagu hai, itna zyada absurd hai ke aadmi kahe ke la haula wala quwwat, kahe ke chhod de ga is ko. koi is se koi problem hi koi hone wala nahin hai, har giz nahin. koi ek aadmi is is se koi asar lene wala nahin hai. lekin jab shorgol karein ge aap to ahmiyat badh jaye gi. shorgol karne ki wajah se ahmiyat badh gayi is ki. maulana, un ka ek aur sawal hai.
1:22:18unhon ne likha hai "one of my students told me that after completing his studies, he would join jihad. i asked him the reason for his doing so. he replied that our brothers are being killed in assam . how can we remain silent at such operation? we have to retaliate." maulana, what is your comment? dekhein, yeh sara muamla yeh hai ke musalmanon ke jo so called jo leader hain, bilkul musalmanon mein third class log jo hain, aa kar ke bolte hain. aur is mein stage par aur woh urdu akhbaron mein sab aata hai.
1:23:00zyada tar urdu akhbaron mein sab baatein hoti hain. woh samajhte hain ke wahan zulm ho raha hai. akhbari reporton mein one sided reporting hoti hai, yak tarfa reporting, yaani khud musalmanon ne kya kiya, yeh nahin hoti. main is ki ek misaal deta hoon ke burma mein aap internet se check kar lijiye ke burma mein mashhoor hai ke burma mein zulm ho raha hai, zulm ho raha hai, zulm ho raha hai. musalmanon ko maar rahe hain. to in dilli ke kuch yahi jo so called leader hain musalmanon ke, unhon ne dilli ke jo burma ka ambassador hai, us ko letter likha ke sahib, aap se milna chahte hain.
1:23:44us jo zulm musalmanon ke khilaf ho raha hai, us se baat karne ke liye. to us ne ek letter likha. us letter ko us ne internet pe daal diya. aap dekh sakte ho us letter ko. burma ke safeer ne, jo dilli mein hai, us ne kaha ke aap log waqiyat se ko ko poori tarah se li jiye. aap be khabar hain is waqeye se . us ne kaha ke wahan par aisa hua ke ek ek buddhist ladki ko, buddhist ladki ko kai musalman ladkon ne gang rape kiya aur phir maar bhi dala us ko.
1:24:22to zahir hai ke use, use, use, use to wahan par ek trigger hona hi tha. yeh sab baatein aap dekh lijiye, internet maujood hai. to is tarah ki hum hum hum huma kaana harkatein jo ki jaati hain, is ko report nahi karte akhbar wale. is ke retaliation ki report karte hain. in ko main kehta hoon one sided reporting. to yeh, yeh, yeh, yeh sab se zyada yeh musalmanon ke akhbar hain, woh aag lagate hain. musalmanon ke akhbar mein sab se zyada one sided reporting hoti hai.
1:24:54main ne ek mazmoon likha tha ke musalmanon ki jo sahafat hai, ye yellow sahafat, yellow journals ki sab se bari misaal hai. jitne musalmanon ke akhbarat the, chahe urdu ho ya angrezi mein hon, sab yellow journals ki misaal hote hain. yaani adhi baat na kehna, adhi baat kehna, ise log bhadak bhadak kar ke kehte hain. to assam mein kuch nahi hai, na burma mein kuch hai. har jagah musalmanon ko batana chahiye ke tum ne jo hamakatein ki thin, us ko band karo. yeh retaliation hai. retaliation ko woh zulm batate hain.
1:25:32burma mein bhi retaliation hai, assam mein bhi retaliation hai. to jo jo talib ilm bechara aisa soch raha hai, woh woh janta hi nahi kuch. is ko haqeeqat khabar nahi. is musalmanon ke akhbar ne parh liya, us ne bas samajhta hai ke yahi waqia hai. halanke musalmanon ke akhbar mein yak tarafah reporting rehti hai. to is ko agar samjha diya jaye ke tum poori soorat-e-haal ko pata karo ke kya hai, to maloom hoga ke yeh musalman innocent nahi hain. yaani musalmanon ka koi innocent dikhate hain. saare urdu urdu akhbarat aur musalmanon ke angrezi akhbar, urdu akhbar jate hain, musalmanon ko innocent dikhate hain, masoom bilkul.
1:26:21isi se log bhadakte hain ke hum to bilkul innocent hain, hamare khilaf khwamkhwah zulm ho raha hai. bhai, yeh bilkul aisa nahi hai. aap is ki ek misaal bhi maine di aap ko. aap internet pe check kar lijiye ke burma ka safeer jo india mein hai, us ne jo khat likha tha, us ko us ne daal diya hai internet par. use us ko download kar ke parh lijiye aap. maulana, agla sawal delhi se hai miss naghma siddiqui ka. unhone aapse poocha hai ke "how can we avoid emotional thinking and develop objective thinking?"