Maulana Wahiduddin Khan
GuidanceQ&AClipsReferencesVideosMoreIn Maulana’s wordsStories Maulana returns toAbout MaulanaFeedbackSign in
Society & Dawah · Q&A

Sachar Committee and reservations for Muslims

“Should Indian Muslims accept the recommendations of the Sachar Committee? Is it correct according to Quran and Hadith? Is it permissible for Muslims to take reservations from the government?”Asked by Muhammad Shah Shahbaz Alam, Delhi

He answers at 55:19 in Islam in Daily Life · 2 min 46 sec

His answer, in his own words
55:19
Maulana agla sawal Dilli se hai, Muhammad Shah Shahabaz Alam Sahab ka . Unhon ne likha hai: "Kya Bharatiya Musalmanon ko kendra sarkar dwara gathit Sachar Committee dwara di gayi recommendation unko maan lena chahiye? Kya yeh Quran aur Hadees ki roshni mein sahi hai? Aur kya sarkar se aarakshan lena Musalmanon ke liye jaayaz hai? Is ke bare mein bataein." Dekhein yeh sab sawalat hamare sawalat nahi hain. Yeh aap jaanein, hum toh in sab baaton ko sochte bhi nahi.
55:56
Hum toh Quran Majeed ki woh aayatein ko le kar sochte hain jis mein likha hua hai ke koi bhi doosra aadmi tumhara mustaqbil nahi bana sakta. Tum khud apna mustaqbil banaoge, banega nahi toh nahi ban sakta. Jo log samajhte hain ke reservation aur Sachar Committee se aap ka future banega, toh main samajhta hoon ke woh, yaani woh Khuda se inkar toh main nahi kahunga, lekin Khuda ko neglect karne ke barabar hai. Kyun ke Quran mein saaf saaf hai ke wahi hoga jo jo tum jo tum mehnat karoge, jitna tum mehnat karoge utna paoge. "Laysa lil insaani illaa maa sagha" .
56:35
Toh aap kyun dekhte hain Sachar Committee ko? Aap kyun mutalba karte hain reservation ka? Apne upar bharosa kijiye. Yeh thinking hi mere nazdeek bilkul jahiliyat ki thinking hai aur Islam ke khilaaf thinking hai ke aap kisi aur par bharosa karein. Apne upar bharosa kijiye. Apne apne apne aap aap par bharosa kijiye. Aap ko Allah Ta'ala ne haath paon diya hai, dimaag diya hai, salahiyat di hai, is ko unfold kijiye. Aur itni misalein hain ke baghair reservation ke aur Sachar Committee ka jab koi naam bhi nahi jaanta tha, tab Dr. Abdul Kalam jaisa insaan bana.
57:15
Dr. Abdul Kalam paida hue ek ghareeb family mein, school ki fees nahi de sakta tha, un ke maa baap nahi de sakte the. Lekin wahi insaan jo hai President of India bana. Toh kahin Sachar ke bete hain, woh kaisa reservation? Logon ko kehte hain in ko motivate kijiye, logon ke muharrik jagaiye. Yeh asal kaam hai. Main toh samajhta hoon ke woh log dushman hain Musalmanon ke jo Sachar Committee ki baatein karte hain aur reservation ki baatein karte hain. Musalmanon ka dost woh hai jo Musalmanon ke yeh bataye ke apni Khuda ki di hui salahiyaton ko unfold karo. Khuda ne jo di hai jo tumhare andar salahiyat, us ko
57:57
unfold karo. Woh toh Islam Musalmanon ka dost hai. Jo in cheezon ko dalta hai Musalmanon ke dimaaghon mein, main us ko Musalmanon ka dushman samajhta hoon. Maulana agla sawal Dilli se hai, Nasir Hussain Qureshi Sahab ka. Unhon ne likha hai: "Chapter number two, verse number 67 mein aaya hai mein Allah Quran mein Allah ne farmaya hai ke hum ne un ke dil par mohar laga di,
All questions he answeredThe whole lecture, from this momentWatch on YouTube

Machine transcription. These are his recorded words, written down by software from the Urdu he speaks — so a line may carry a misheard word. Every timestamp above opens the video at that second: one tap and you can hear him say it. Quote it as speech, and link to the moment.