59:05molana, agla sawal dilli se hai doctor muslima siddiqi ka. unhon ne aap se poocha hai: "what should we do in the night of 15 shaban?" dekhiye, 15 shaban ki koi haqeeqat nahi hai, yeh to riwaj hai musalmanon mein. baqi hai ke jo rawayati aitbar se jo is ka tasawwur hai, to meri kitab hai "nasri taqdeer", is ko aap parh lijie. yani koi musnad hadithon mein is ke bare mein kuch nahi milta hai, lekin jo bhi hai, is ke bare mein maine kuch mazmoon likh diya hai, is ko aap parh lijie. "nasri
59:48taqdeer" hai, isi mein hai na ji? "nasri taqdeer" ek kitab hai. molana, agla question dilli se hai miss satti malhotra ka. unhon ne likha hai: "can we say that chanting is only repetition of words and there is no mind being used for it?" since islam is a mind based religion, therefore islam does not permit chanting. aap jo log chanting karte hain, un se pooch lijie. maine un logon se poocha hai, woh sahi is choran ko, theek theek is choran ko samajhte hain ke isi se dooda khush hota hai. is choran se is ke liye woh chanting karte hain. khas tarah ka is choran jis ko kehte hain, jis ko hamare qari log jis ko kehte hain "sahi makharij" ada karte hain.
1:00:41kyun ke makharij ya is choran ko ahmiyat de di gayi hai. yeh musalmanon ki yahi baat hai ke theek theek makharij ke sath ada kar diya jaye to bas ho gaya. unhon ne kaha theek theek achaanak kar diya hai to ho gaya. is mein mind ka koi application nahi hai. to main samajhta hoon ke is ka taluq mazhab se nahi hai. yeh ek riwaj hai jo baad ke zamane mein bana hai. asal mazhab mein kabhi yeh nahi tha. aisa
1:01:13molana, agla sawal dilli se hai jameel akhtar sahib ka.