Why do Pakistanis leave Pakistan despite struggle?
“If Muslims had finally succeeded after a long and hard struggle to carve out a separate land for themselves and lead a religious life, then why is it that all the Pakistanis leave Pakistan at the very first opportunity available to them?”Asked by Dr. Muslama Siddiqui, Delhi
He answers at 1:12:48 in The Lesson of History · 2 min 51 sec
1:12:48Maulana, agla sawal Dr. Saleema Siddiqui ne kiya hai Delhi se. aur unhone likha hai ke Please comment on this fact that if Muslims had finally succeeded after a long and hard struggle to carve out a separate land for themselves and lead a religious life, then why is it that all the Pakistanis leave Pakistan at the very first opportunity available to them? dekhen, Pakistan banwaya gaya tha mazhab ke naam par, lekin is ka mazhab se koi ta'alluq nahi tha. woh to ek jazbati qaumiyat, yani qaumiyat bhi nahi thi. is ka mazhab se koi ta'alluq nahi, Islam se koi ta'alluq nahi. to wahan jo gaye log, bhaag bhaag kar ke, dekha ke Pakistan mein zyada mawaqe nahi hain aur Europe mein zyada mawaqe hain, America mein zyada mawaqe hain, to wahan bhaag bhaag gaye.
1:13:43kyunke koi zehan to barabar tha nahi. na Pakistan banne se pehle, na Pakistan banne ke baad, un ke andar koi deeni zehan tha. deeni zehan ka matlab hai ke dawat Allah ka kaam karne ka zehan. mislan, yeh tha hi nahi. woh to, yani un ka maadi zehan pehle bhi tha, maadi zehan ab bhi tha. yani pre Pakistan bhi maadi zehan tha, post Pakistani maadi zehan tha. to jahan dekha ke jahan kamai hai, wahan bhaag bhaag rahe hain.
1:14:16Pakistan ka yeh yeh to naarah sirf tha ke Pakistan ka matlab La Ilaha Illallah. yeh sirf naarah tha, is ka Islam se koi ta'alluq nahi tha. aur dekhen, yeh bid'at hai. kyunke mazhab ke naam par koi ilaqa alag karwana, yeh to kisi paighambar ne nahi kiya. Rasool Allah ne, Sahaba ne aisa kabhi bhi nahi kiya ke Islam ke naam par kahein ke hum ko itna hissa baant kar do. yeh to ek is qism ki siyasat to is ka Islam se koi ta'alluq nahi hai. taqseem ki siyasat bilashuba is ka Islam se koi ta'alluq nahi hai. yani parties of partition, is ka Islam se koi ta'alluq nahi hai.
1:14:55to jab Islam se ta'alluq hi is ka nahi hai, to wahan Islam kahan se aaye ga? jab parties of partition jo hain, it itself was unislamic, to kaise mumkin hai ke wahan Islam aa jaye? to yeh to ek ek hungama tha, is ka koi ta'alluq aqal se bhi nahi tha. Islam to bohat door ki baat hai. aaj dekhen, Pakistan ek failed state hai. failed state hai woh. is se zyada tar harkatein India mein hui hain. to yeh is ka ta'alluq na to Pakistan, is ka ta'alluq na to Islam se hai, na aqal se hai. yeh ek jazbati hungama tha, pehle bhi aur ab bhi hai.
1:15:40Maulana, agla sawal Dr. Fareeda Khanam ne Delhi se kiya hai. aur unhone likha hai ke Muslims do not raise any objection to the relocation of masjid in Arab countries, but they do not accept the same principle for India.