Helping people accept unattainable ideals
“Everybody accepts the fact that all are free but are not able to accept the next step that this ideal cannot be achieved and run towards ideal. How to make people understand this simple thing?”Asked by Naghma Siddiqui, New Delhi
He answers at 48:35 in The Search of Man · 5 min 8 sec
48:35maulana, agla sawal hai miss naghma siddiqui ka new delhi se. unhon ne likha hai: "Everybody accept the fact that all are free but are not able to accept the next step that this ideal cannot be achieved and run towards ideal. how to make people understand this simple thing?" main jo maine kiya woh yeh tha ke poori tareekh maine dekha ke ideal koi achieve nahin kar saka, chahe woh king ho, chahe baldiya ho, chahe kuch bhi ho. to pehle chahe ke aakhir apna ideal ko achieve koi nahin kar pata.
49:21tab maine daryaft kiya ke ke woh Allah ka jo creation plan hai, us ke khilaaf hai. yeh yeh karna chahiye aadmi ko. maulana, agla question aaya hai: "jo cheez Allah ke creation plan ke khilaaf ho, woh aap kaise achieve karein?" misaal ke taur par aam mein aam ka phal nikalta hai account laakhon se. ab aam ke phal mein aap save bhi karna chahein to niklega nahin.
49:55saaf saaf, yaani bilkul simple sa is ka raaz hai. maulana, next question hai zaheeruddin sahib ka raichur se. unhon ne likha hai: "maulana, to understand what is achievable or what is not requires lot of wisdom and insight. how can one acquire them?" nahin, har aadmi sochta hai. log kehte hain ke aag jalati hai, kaha aag apne haath daalta hai to aag mein test karne ke liye
50:28aadmi sincere ho to har cheez ke baare mein woh aise karega ke us ko jaanche ga, examine karega aur pata karega ke yeh achievable hai ya nahin. jis tarah se aadmi aag pe haath nahin daalta, is tarah se woh doosre kaam bhi bache ga in achievable goals se. maulana, agla question hai mubeen sahib ka jamia nagar se . unhon ne likha hai: "musalmanon mein alag alag firqe ka zimmedaar kaun hai? aur Khuda ke haan agarche in logon ne deen ki ghair mamooli, ghair mamooli kaam anjaam diya hai, to in logon ka anjaam Khuda ke haan kya hoga?" Khuda kya?
51:10aap aap ka yeh kaam nahin hai. apne baare mein bhi kya pata hai aap ko? aap ko Khuda ka kya hoga? yeh to ghair dori sawal hai. baqi jo masla hai, us ke baare mein jaanna chahein, aap hamari kitaab padh lijiyye: "tajdeed deen". is mein is masle par aaya hai. yeh bohat hi galat tareeqa hai ke Khuda ke haan anjaam kya hoga, yeh aap ek soch lein. aap ka apna anjaam kya hoga, yeh pata nahin hai. to doosre ke baare mein kaise aap sochte hain? yeh bilkul galat hai. baqi jo wajah hai fiqah bandi ki, us ko aap jaanna chahein to hamari kitaab padh lijiyye: "tajdeed deen".
51:52maulana, agla question hai khwaja kaleemuddin sahib ka pennsylvania usa se. unhon ne likha hai: "one of the brotherhood members recently in egypt declared that now they will resort back to violence to achieve their goals." my question to you maulana sahib: "why doesn't man refuse? man refuse to learn lesson from his or her his or their own experiences?" dekhein, in logon ne jo galat ek galat masla bana rakha hai, woh yeh hai ke kaamyaab hue to wazeh hai: mar gaya to shaheed, yeh koi Islam nahin hai. woh sochte hain ke agar hum kaamyaab nahin hue political system mein to lad kar kuch log maare gaye to shaheed to ho jayenge. yeh bilkul galat hai.
52:44islam mein aisi koi taleem nahi hai.