Logic of punishment in grave before judgment
“All the records of human beings will be declared on the day of judgment, and the punishment or reward will be decided on the basis of the performance. Then what is the logic behind punishment of the grave? Why does an individual start getting punishment since he is put down in the grave, though the punishment is to be decided in the Hereafter?”Asked by شاہنواز ظفر, دلی
He answers at 1:05:20 in The Importance of Team Work · 3 min 1 sec
1:05:20Maulana, agla sawal Delhi se aaya hai Mr Shahnawaz Zafar ka. unhon ne likha hai: "All the records of human beings will be declared on the day of judgment, and the punishment or reward will be decided on the basis of the performance. Then what is the logic behind azab e qabr ? Why an individual starts getting punishment since he is put down in qabr, though the punishment is to be decided in akhirat? Why an angel comes in qabr and asks some questions? Why we all know that Almighty Allah will do a question answer session on the day of judgment, and then He will take a performance-based decision?
1:06:07How can we understand it in reference to the ultimate justice of Almighty Allah? dekhiye, is mein ghalat fehmi yeh hai ke qabr ke hawale se jo saza ka zikr hai hadith mein, baaz hadithon mein, woh alamati hai. Alamati yani is ka matlab hai ke isi gadhe mein azab ho raha hai. Is ka matlab har giz yeh nahi hai. Is ka matlab yeh hai ke maut ke baad insan ka apne anjam ko bhugtna. Yaani qabr alamat hai is baat ki ke aadmi ek daure se nikal kar doosre daure tak pahunch gaya. Qabr ki hesiyat alamat ki hai, woh gadhe ki nahi hai.
1:06:58Is gadhe mein jo body dala gaya, woh body toh kuch bhi nahi, woh toh mitti hai. Use insan toh farishte le gaye, jahan le gaye. Toh is is tarah ki riwayaton mein qabr ka lafz alamati taur par aaya hai, yeh batane ke liye ke maut ke baad insan ka muamla Allah ke samne pesh aata hai. Doosri baat yeh hai ke hum sochte hain is duniya mein time and space ke term mein. Yeh time space relative hai. Yeh baat toh Einstein ke is mein sabit ho chuki hai ke yeh time and space ka concept jo hai, sara ka sara relative hai, real nahi hai.
1:07:42Yeh Yeh jo aap sochte hain time ke ishtihar mein ho aur space ke ishtihar mein, yeh sab ka sab relative hai. Maut ke baad aap ek aur duniya mein pahunch jaate hain jis mein time space ka concept khatm ho jata hai, bilkul doosra aa jata hai. Neeche yeh question jo hai, main samajhta hoon ke Einstein ke jo theory of relativity hai, us ne is sawal ka khatma kar diya hai. Is sawal ka ab koi relevance baqi nahi raha.
1:08:22Maulana, agla sawal hai Delhi se Maulana Shariq Hussain ne kiya hai. Unhone likha hai: "Team ke sath kaam karte hue pesh aane wali shikayaton ko dil se kaise khatam kiya jaye?