“In comparison to individual promises, it is not necessary to fulfill collective promises. What is the evidence for this in the Quran and Hadith?”Asked by مس حامدہ بانو, دلی
maulana, dilli se agla sawal hai miss hamida bano ka. unhon ne likha hai: "individual promise ke muqable mein collective promise ko poora karna zaroori nahin. quran aur hadith mein is ki daleel kya hai?" maine yeh lafz istemal nahin kiya. collective promise, yeh to haq ka apna lafz hai. maine to kabhi nahin. maine kaha ke siyasat ke mamlaat jo hote hain, un mein bohat zyada up and down hota hai, bohat zyada farq hota hai. insan ke qabze mein nahin ke halaat ko wahi to barqarar rakhe.
aap ne agar kisi se kaha hai ke main tum ko das rupiya doon ga to woh aap ke qabze mein hai, woh aap ke qabze se bahar nahin hai. lekin jo siyasat ke mamlaat hote hain, woh is mein up and down hota rehta hai. woh kisi ke bas mein nahin ke woh us ko yani ek hi halat baqi rakhe. is liye is ka muamla alag ho jata hai. alag agar agar halaat na badlen to baqi rahega woh. yani agar halaat na badlen to baqi rahega. it depends upon situation
ji haan. maulana, agla sawal hai saharanpur se doctor aslam ka. unhon ne poocha hai: "maulana sahib, after rasool Allah, who succeeded in forming the best team for da'wah work?"
Machine transcription. These are his recorded words, written down by software from the Urdu he speaks — so a line may carry a misheard word. Every timestamp above opens the video at that second: one tap and you can hear him say it. Quote it as speech, and link to the moment.