Maulana Wahiduddin Khan
GuidanceQ&AClipsReferencesVideosMoreIn Maulana’s wordsStories Maulana returns toAbout MaulanaFeedbackSign in
Hadith · Q&A

Interpretation of hadith on being killed repeatedly

“Muslims, to prove their concept of war correct, narrate this hadith: "I love that I be killed in the way of Allah, then brought to life, then killed, then given life, then killed." Mawlana, what is the correct interpretation of this hadith?”Asked by فرہاد عمری, دہلی

He answers at 1:06:46 in Spirit of Ramadan · 2 min 49 sec

His answer, in his own words
1:06:46
Maulana, yeh agla sawal aaya hai Maulana Farhad Umri sahib ka Delhi se. musalman apne waar concept ko sahi sabit karne ke liye yeh hadith bayan karte hain: "mein yeh pasand karta hoon ke mein Allah ke raste mein qatl kiya jaon, phir zinda kiya jaon, phir qatl kiya jaon, phir mujhe zindagi mile, phir qatl kiya jaon." Maulana, is hadith ka sahi interpretation kya hai? dekhiye, yeh sochiye ke kya Rasool Allah salallaho alaihi wasallam nauzubillah nauzubillah munafiq the? Aap aap yeh keh sakte hain ke jab aap ko pasand tha to aisa kiya kyun nahi?
1:07:29
kitabon se padhiye, aap Rasool Allah salallaho alaihi wasallam kabhi bhi jang mein shareek nahi hote the. Bahar un ka ek areesh lafz aata hai, areesh kehte hain jhopra. battlefield se bahar ek areesh banta tha, jhopra. Is mein rehte the. Aap kabhi talwar le kar Uhud mein ya Badr mein kabhi khud se nahi lade? to nauzubillah ke aap kahein ke nauzubillah nauzubillah Rasool Allah munafiq the ? Kaha to yeh aur kiya? Un ka ulta kabhi lade nahi? Aap kitabon mein padh lijiye, aap battlefield mein nahi hote the, areesh mein hote the jo bahar banta tha, wahan se dekh dekhte the bas aur dua karte the, sajde mein dua karte the.
1:08:13
jo log is hadith ko le kar kehte hain, unhein sab se pehle sochna chahiye ke kya nauzubillah nauzubillah Rasool Allah munafiq the? Kaha kuch kiya kuch. is liye aap ko is hadith ki aisi tafsir karni padegi jis mein Rasool Allah yeh yeh sabit na hota ke nauzubillah Rasool Allah munafiq the. yeh sab mein likh chuka hoon is hadith ke bare mein, mein likh chuka hoon, aap padh sakte hain.
All questions he answeredThe whole lecture, from this momentWatch on YouTube

Machine transcription. These are his recorded words, written down by software from the Urdu he speaks — so a line may carry a misheard word. Every timestamp above opens the video at that second: one tap and you can hear him say it. Quote it as speech, and link to the moment.