Ibn Taymiyyah's mistake on Bila Faimi

maulana, agla sawal Pakistan se aya hai, misṭar aamir bin yusuf sahib ka. unho ne likha hai ke aap ne aaj ki taqreer mein jo ibn taimiya ka zikr kiya, to kya is ka matlab yeh hai ke imam ibn taimiya se ghalṭi hui blisfaimi ke moamle mein, aur musalman is ghalṭi ko repeat kar rahe hain? is ke bare mein batayein.

dekhiye, masla ibn taimiya ka nahi, har insan ka hai. har insan khata kar sakta hai, yeh to hadith sabit hai. qul bani adam khaṭṭan har insan khata karta hai, to is mein ibn taimiya koi exepshan nahi hai. to yeh koi aisi baat nahi hai jo main ne koi anokhi kahi ho.

saare logo ka is pe ittefaq hai ke insan ghalṭi karta hai. aap ko haq hai ke is ki ghalṭi ka tajziya karein, tajziya karein. imam abu hanifa ne kaha tha ke agar ek ek ek ek fatwa hai koi main ne diya hai, agar tum ko koi hadith mil jaye is fatwe ke khilaf, to mere fatwe ko pathar mar

do, pathar pe mar do, mere fatwe ko chhod do, hadith ko qabool kar lo. yeh to hote hi rehta hai. ulama mein ikhtilaf, saare ulama mein aapas mein ikhtilafat hue hain. isi liye yeh koi aisi baat nahi hai ke kisi ki kitaab muqaddas nahi hai.

quran ke tareeqay se kisi bhi shakhs ki kitaab quran ki tarah muqaddas nahi hai. imam malik ke baray mein kaha jata hai ke woh jab madine mein rasool allah qabr ke paas dars hadith dete thay, to wahan aik atay thay ke koi bhi insan aisa nahi hai jis ki baaton mein se kuch lainay ka ho, kuch na lainay ka ho, siwaye illa sahib bahadur qabr.

to yeh to aik muttafiq alaih baat hai, is mein koi do raaye nahi. maulana, agla sawal dili se hai, miss naghma siddiqui ka.