“In a narration in Musnad Ahmad, it is mentioned that the first link of Islam to break will be 'Hukm' and 'Salah'. What is the meaning of 'Hukm' and 'Salah' in this context?”Asked by مولانا زکوان ندوی, دلی
maulana ye sawal dilli se hai maulana zikwan nadvi ka unhon ne likha hai musnad ahmad ki ek riwayat mein bataya gaya hai ke sab se pehle islam ki jo kadi toote gi wo hai hukm aur salat is riwayat mein hukm aur salat ka matlab kya hai is ke bare mein batayen dekhen hukm ka matlab to hota hai political power salat ka matlab hai namaz to lekin ye lafz jo dono lafz jo hain wo apne spirit ke aitbar se istemal hue hain literal mani mein nahi istemal hue hain ye ani kyunke ap dekhen kisi bhi ummat mein kabhi aisa nahi hua hai ke koi ka nizam hi na rahe ka namaz roza na rahe ye to har ummat mein rehta hai musalmanon bhi baki dhanche ke aitbar se to ek hai siyasat power ka dhanche ek hai namaz ka dhanche to is hadith mein ye nahi kaha gaya hai ke siyasat dhanche hi khatam ho jaye ga ya namaz ka dhanche khatam ho jaye ga aisa nahi kaha gaya hai balke spirit ke aitbar se khatam ho jaye ga yani hukumat spirit ke aitbar se kya hai wo hai adl
adl par qaim ho to wo wo sachi spirit par qaim hoga aur namaz ka jo spirit hai wo hai khushu to khud quran khud hadith hi sabit hai ke namaz nahi khatam ho jaye gi dhanche baki rahe ga rooh khatam ho jaye gi mislan dekhen ek hadith hai ke bad ke zamaney mein ye wahi zamana hai jis mein jis ke bare mein is hadith mein is ka ishara kiya gaya hai is zamaney mein kya hoga masajid mamra wahe kharab min al huda un ki masjidain bhari hui hongi lekin wo hidayat se khali hongi to is ka matlab kya hua ke in ka bazahir ek political structure bhi hoga in ke haan hukumat bhi in ke haan hogi lekin adl ke spirit se khali hogi aise bazahir ke masjidon mein khoob namazi bhare hue honge lekin wahan bhi khushu ki spirit maujood nahi hogi ye matlab hai is ka to khulasa ye hai ke is ka matlab ye hai ke islam bait bar form to baki rahe ga lekin bait bar spirit wo khatam ho jaye ga
ek ke baad ek maulana agla sawal tamil nadu se kiya hai maulana iqbal umri ne unhon ne likha hai maulana ek sahab ne kaha ke islam ka nizam mukammal nahi hai to phir konsa nizam mukammal hai maulana is ki ghalati wazeh karen dekhen ye sawal jo hai khud ghalat sawal hai
Machine transcription. These are his recorded words, written down by software from the Urdu he speaks — so a line may carry a misheard word. Every timestamp above opens the video at that second: one tap and you can hear him say it. Quote it as speech, and link to the moment.