“The political interpretation of religion is undoubtedly a wrong interpretation, due to which most Muslims today are misguided. Then how did it happen that during the era of the Righteous Caliphs there was also political conflict, even though they were the ones who understood religion in its original form? Please explain this.”Asked by شاہنواز ظفر, دلی
maulana agla sawal dilli se kya hai shahnawaz zafar sahib ne unhon ne likha hai deen ki siyasi taabeer beshak ek galat taabeer hai jis ki wajah se aaj ke beshtar musalman bhatke hue hain to phir aisa kaise hua ke khulafa-e-rashideen ke daur mein bhi siyasi takrao hua jabke woh log deen ko is ke asal roop mein samajhne wale the is ke bare mein hamein batayen dekhen kya takrao ka matlab main nahin keh raha yeh main nahin keh raha hoon ke political interpretation se takrao paida hota hai takrao ki to bohat si baaten hain sadak pe log takra jate hain rasta nahin diya to takra gaye to takrao ke mukhtalif asbab hote hain wahan par jo takrao tha yani hazrat muawiya mein hazrat ali mein woh takrao jo tha us ki buniyad political interpretation nahin tha woh darasal yeh tha ke hazrat usman ki ki shahadat hui thi un ko qatal kiya gaya tha to masla yeh tha ke jo qatilin the un ko saza di jaye to hazrat muawiya jo the un ka israr yeh tha ke qatilin jo hain woh un ke wirsa ko hawale kiye jayen hazrat usman aur hazrat muawiya dono ek hi qabile ke the yani bani umayya se dono ka taalluq tha
to un ka jo jo wahan par jo riwaj chala raha tha pehle se woh yahi tha ke qatil ko maqtul ke wirsa ko hawale kar diya jata tha phir woh jis tarah chahen us ko saza den yeh riwaj tha wahan to hazrat ali kehte the ke nahin hum us ko adalat mein jayenge wahan par karwai hogi adalti faisle ke تحت wahan par nafiz kiya jayega jo jo tay hoga yeh yeh yeh do raay ka takrao tha do raah ka takrao tha yeh barhte barhte jang shuru ikhtiyar ki gayi to wahan jo takrao pesh aaya woh is ke sabab doosra tha political interpretation se koi talluq nahi tha maulana agla sawal roorkee se hai sajid an
Machine transcription. These are his recorded words, written down by software from the Urdu he speaks — so a line may carry a misheard word. Every timestamp above opens the video at that second: one tap and you can hear him say it. Quote it as speech, and link to the moment.