Maulana Wahiduddin Khan
All references

Maulana Wahiduddin Khan and His Critics: A Response to Misinterpretations. November 26, 2024

27 references in this lecture
Download
Quran 33:31 · Al-Ahzab
Researching whether classical scholars ever said 'uswa kaamila'
“Kya Maulana Rasoolullah ke uswa ko kaamila nahi manate?”
Quran 33:31 · Al-Ahzab
“molana anayatullah umri sahab ne achhe tareeqe se wazahat ki ke Allah ta'ala ne Quran mein jo aswa hasna ka lafz istemaal kiya hai uski sahih tawjeeh kya”
Sahih al-Bukhari, Hadith no. 1
Spirit over form: Maulana's core discovery about worship
“Sabse pehli hadees hai: a'maal ka daar-o-madar niyat par hai.”
Al-Firdaws bi-Ma'thur al-Khitab by al-Daylami, Hadith no. 7935
Spirit over form: Maulana's core discovery about worship
“Sabse pehli hadees hai: a'maal ka daar-o-madar niyat par hai.”
Shu'ab al-Iman by al-Bayhaqi, Hadith no. 1908
Spirit over form: Maulana's core discovery about worship
“Sabse pehli hadees hai: a'maal ka daar-o-madar niyat par hai.”
Quran 51:56 · Adh-Dhariyat
Spirit over form: Maulana's core discovery about worship
“Sabse pehli hadees hai: a'maal ka daar-o-madar niyat par hai.”
Al-Firdaws bi-Ma'thur al-Khitab by al-Daylami, Hadith no. 7935
Spirit over form: Maulana's core discovery about worship
“Sabse pehli hadees hai: a'maal ka daar-o-madar niyat par hai.”
Quran 107:4 · Al-Ma'un
Spirit over form: Maulana's core discovery about worship
“Sabse pehli hadees hai: a'maal ka daar-o-madar niyat par hai.”
Sahih Muslim, Hadith no. 1718
“to is silsile mein jo mashhoor hadith hum sunte hain 'man ahdatha fi amrina hadha ma laysa minhu fa huwa radd' to fi amrina hadha yahan jo hai bohat hi crucial text hai yeh text ka jo hai crucial point hai kah 'fi amrina' se kia murad hai al-amr woh kia hai a jismein aap jo hai kuch innovation karein ge to woh hai a Islam usko reject karta hai is baat ko samajhne ki”
Sahih Muslim, Hadith no. 2363
Prophet and date-palm pollination: worldly vs revealed knowledge
“Rasoolullah ek martaba dates ke baagh se guzar rahe the...”
Musnad al-Darmi, Hadith no. 210
Ibn Mas'ud rebukes an innovated dhikr circle in Kufa
“Kufa ki masjid mein humne ek bohot hi strange cheez dekhi.”
Sahih al-Bukhari, Hadith no. 631
Ibn Mas'ud rebukes an innovated dhikr circle in Kufa
“Kufa ki masjid mein humne ek bohot hi strange cheez dekhi.”
Sahih Muslim, Hadith no. 1297
Ibn Mas'ud rebukes an innovated dhikr circle in Kufa
“Kufa ki masjid mein humne ek bohot hi strange cheez dekhi.”
Sahih Muslim, Hadith no. 2363
“agar Maulana ne is tarah ka koi work kiya hai aur ismein Maulana se ghalti hui hai to zaroor hum ulama ko yeh haq hai ke unko unke work ko jo hai heresy kahen hum bidat kahen lekin agar Maulana ne aisa koi kaam kiya hai jo intaha ilm be amoor e dunya kam ya discipline type category mein aata ho to usko bidat kehna apni besirteej ka jo hai khula aelan”
Sirat Ibn Hisham, vol. 2, p. 192
“goya ke iske andar apne innovation ka raasta apnaya ek sahabi ne badr ki jang ke waqt kaha ke rasool allah jahan aap camp kiye hue hain yeh koi jagah nahi hai”
Jami' Bayan al-Ilm by Ibn Abd al-Barr: 608
“عبادت کے نام پر حالانکہ اس میں جو ہے full stop لگا ہوا تھا اور بعد میں ہمارے علماء نے یہ کہا کہ ما ترک الاول للاخریشی عہ جس چیز میں رسول اللہ نے ڈور کھلا رکھا تھا اس سلسلے میں ہمارے”
Sahih Muslim, Hadith no. 523
“aur isi tarah johe qadriya aur jabriya jaisi yeh isi tarah johe sifat khuda wandi mein johe ulama ke maslak se hatna yeh sab johe bidat mein shumar hoga isi tarah johe nabuwat ko johe rasool allah sallallahu alaihi wasallam ne kaha ke ana khatamun nabiyyin”
Quran 33:45 · Al-Ahzab
“maloom hota hai kah quran kehta hai kah in arsalna kshah da om bsh ra on zira odaai aliallah bad ni ws”
Quran 60:4 · Al-Mumtahanah
“sirf rasool Allah ke liye istemal nahin kiya gaya balkeh hazrat Ibrahim alaihsalam ke liye bhi istemal”
Sharh Mushkil al-Athar by Al-Tahawi: 5059
Why criticism of scholars is legitimate in Islam
“Tanqeed ka matlab hota hai sahih aur bure mein farq karna.”
Musnad al-Darmi: 675
Why criticism of scholars is legitimate in Islam
“Tanqeed ka matlab hota hai sahih aur bure mein farq karna.”
Sahih Muslim, Hadith no. 2363
“intibaqi umoor ke andar jaise ke an tum aalam bi amri dunyah kum ke jumle mein Rasool Allah ne bataya”
Quran 4:83 · An-Nisa
“Quran ka lafz hoga istinbat yeh aur woh hai fuqaha ka lafz hoga ijtihad jaise Bukhari ke andar woh hai”
Sahih al-Bukhari, Hadith no. 7352
“lo ijtahada al hakimu fa inna khata'a faluhu ajrun wa inna asaba faluhu ajrun hadith iska makot toh woh hai Maulana ke kaam ko ijtihad kehti hai aur Quran isko istinbat kehta hai agar Maulana ne aisi koi ghalati ki hoti”