Maulana Wahiduddin Khan
GuidanceQ&AClipsReferencesVideosMoreIn Maulana’s wordsStories Maulana returns toAbout MaulanaFeedbackSign in
All lectures

Maulana Wahiduddin Khan and His Critics A Response to Misinterpretations. November 26, 2024

Full lecture
Clip length
References in this lecture 27
Quran 33:31 · Al-Ahzab
Quran 33:31 · Al-Ahzab
Sahih al-Bukhari, Hadith no. 1
Al-Firdaws bi-Ma'thur al-Khitab by al-Daylami, Hadith no. 7935
Shu'ab al-Iman by al-Bayhaqi, Hadith no. 1908
Quran 51:56 · Adh-Dhariyat
Al-Firdaws bi-Ma'thur al-Khitab by al-Daylami, Hadith no. 7935
Quran 107:4 · Al-Ma'un
Sahih Muslim, Hadith no. 1718
Sahih Muslim, Hadith no. 2363
All 27 references →
5 min 2 sec
•••
Why Maulana always addresses Muslims' faults
“Kyun Maulana musalmanon ko hamesha ghalat batate hain?”
1 min 36 sec
•••
Muslims as da'i, need for a peaceful dawah environment
“Maulana mानते hain Muslim ki asal hasiyat da'i ki hai.”
4 min 35 sec
•••
Is Maulana's work reaction or genuine scholarship?
“Kya Maulana ka kaam psychology of reaction par khada hai?”
52 sec
•••
Maulana's 'Last Discovery': dying with zero negativity
“'My Last Discovery of the World' ke unwan se Maulana ne likha.”
2 min 55 sec
•••
Critique isn't reaction: surgeon and traffic-sign analogies
“Jaise doctor surgery kare, kya usko negative kaha jata hai?”
27 sec
•••
Surgeon analogy: correction isn't negativity
“Kya sarjan ke kaam ko koi negative treatment kehta hai?”
41 sec
•••
Road-sign analogy: warnings aren't insults
“Road par 'accident prone area' likha ho, kya woh manfi hai?”
5 min 7 sec
•••
Researching whether classical scholars ever said 'uswa kaamila'
“Kya Maulana Rasoolullah ke uswa ko kaamila nahi manate?”
2 min 38 sec
•••
Shocking find: 'uswa kaamila' missing from classical tafsirs
“Poore software mein mujhe 'uswa kaamila' ka lafz nahi mila.”
42 sec
•••
The phrase 'uswa kaamila' appears nowhere in tafsir
“Yeh mere liye shocking news thi ke lafz kahin nahi tha.”
5 min 51 sec
•••
Spirit over form: Maulana's core discovery about worship
“Sabse pehli hadees hai: a'maal ka daar-o-madar niyat par hai.”
2 min 6 sec
•••
Worship without spirit isn't accepted, Maulana's discovery
“Yeh sawal bataata hai Maulana aur doosre ulama mein farq kya tha.”
29 sec
•••
Two hadiths: deeds judged by intent and presence of heart
“Innama al-a'maalu bin-niyaat — a'maal ka daar-o-madar niyat par hai.”
2 min 10 sec
•••
Quran's warning about prayer performed without presence of heart
“'Alladhina hum an salaatihim saahoon' — namaziyon ke liye barbadi kyun?”
16 sec
•••
Speaker's personal reason for following Maulana
“Mera Maulana se judne ka maqsad yehi hai ke Islam zinda ho.”
4 min 26 sec
•••
Prophet and date-palm pollination: worldly vs revealed knowledge
“Rasoolullah ek martaba dates ke baagh se guzar rahe the...”
3 min 53 sec
•••
Ibn Mas'ud rebukes an innovated dhikr circle in Kufa
“Kufa ki masjid mein humne ek bohot hi strange cheez dekhi.”
1 min 39 sec
•••
Pebble-counting dhikr circles and the Companion's shock
“Log halqe bana kar kankariyan gin gin kar zikr kar rahe the.”
5 min 15 sec
•••
Why criticism of scholars is legitimate in Islam
“Tanqeed ka matlab hota hai sahih aur bure mein farq karna.”
57 sec
•••
Defining criticism vs slander in Islam
“Islam mein buri cheez tanqeed nahi, tanqees aur ta'ayyub hai.”
1 min 46 sec
•••
Old woman publicly corrects Caliph Umar on mahr
“Ek boodhi khatoon khadi hokar boli: Umar, aapko yeh haq kahan se mila?”
53 sec
•••
Umar's prayer for those who point out his faults
“Rahimallahu imra'an ahda ilayya uyoobi — jo mere ayb bataye, Allah us par reham kare.”
2 min 1 sec
•••
What 'tajdeed' (renewal) actually means in Maulana's work
“Pehle log ko yeh nahi pata ke tajdeed hoti kya hai.”
5 min 57 sec
•••
Clarifying the 'Christ model vs Muhammadi model' controversy
“Maulana ki kitab 'Qayamat ka Ailaan' ko lekar bawaal khada kiya gaya.”
2 min 33 sec
•••
Why Maulana pointed to Christ's non-violent model today
“Insaaf se kaam lena zaroori hai jab kisi ki baat samajhte hain.”
41 sec
•••
Maulana's devotion to hadith and the Prophet's example
“Agar sirf Quran hota, hadith na hoti, to main pagal ho jata.”